It looks kinda cool but there are a lot of shapes going on there. It might look sleeker without that thing hanging down on the back. Whatever is hanging down in the front appears to get in the way of the trigger finger. At least they toned down the chrome and it looks like they got rid of the flippy-do-thing.
So glad I did a search on this subject as I was about to start a thread inquiring about these.
Saw the movie this last weekend. At first I thought my old eyes were misinterpreting these "new" phasers with the standard ones.
It's OB10's impression that these phasers were from the U.S.S. Franklin. It's an older ship, therefore the phasers are more "retro" that the standard issued phasers. It also explained to me why they looked so extra bulky in Spock's and McCoy's hands.