I really appreciate all the comments! I really had tried clay on a test piece and was not happy with the results... It was not oil based and dried...cracking badly. I have seen the sites and links for people that truly model in clay and I admire their skill, but I have never done that and not sure the skill will come that quickly LOL!
The whole reason I was interested in spackle as a potential medium is that I want to make a single mold off a part. Then pour it in plastic. The mold needn't be as sturdy as bondo and I was hoping to shorten prep time.
I have learned more than you probably think from these comments as it is helping me rule out ideas I had considered..
I believe that Surreals' valuable points lead me to making sure that my pep "core" be super rigid and inflexible if I intend on using my desired spackle method. I do like Dancin_fools points about making it strong enough only for my desired purpose as It is intended to be a "One-Off" type framework... I might investigate clay, but was very glad about the sulfur based clay comment.
I have to do some serious research this weekend and will chase some threads and product info... I can be stubborn, but as a hospital administrator I have to listen to my experts and voices of experience then make decisions, sometimes ones I dont like. Bondo is cheap, I can have all I need tomorrow and a sander to boot if need be.
I also for the sake of ruling things out, tried my idea of adding a sandable wood glue to my spackle compound tonight before I spread it on my old test boot. This is another disadvantage as it has longer drying times than bondo, so it will be tomorrow or saturday before I can sand on it due to drying and work issues that arose tonight.
This is actually a great test platform as I did not fiberglass the inside. If it can handle an even moderate amount of flexing I will consider it a success. If the flexing cracks it, it will be an epic fail and I will have to either make every thing very very rigid to the max or change my game plan, and go with fiberglass and bondo. Truly the question is, Can I get pieces, especially the larger, chest and back pieces rigid enough to succeed with plan A. Not looking so good right at this moment..:cry
I want this to succeed and persisting in the face of evident failure would be useless and result in rebuilding of Peps and while I love building them LOL I do not relish building too many duplicated parts over and over...Pepakura hell of a thousand rebuilds! I would rather take a five finger death punch to the chest than that LOL! :confused
I am sorry to always be long winded, (it helps me think), but as always I appreciate the wisdom and kind words of support!
M