I’m not happy that I found the 2011 auction information that matched the auction gun.
I would have been in awe if, after almost 50 years, more of the ANH hero would have surfaced. If that Mauser had 2813 on the side and the barrel was right and the side had repairs from the scope mounts bolts or mystery disc, man I would have been happy. You know bapty have searched their inventory for that because they know that would be like printing money. With the $1M price of the last one, anyone from the production team who might have taken it would have already cashed in knowing it would be even higher.
Hopefully in the end though, finding the truth about this non-fully intact, non-matching anything c96 reduces the stupidity of these auctions. The amount of detailed knowledge of members of the RPF is going to catch their BS every time.
Something to keep in mind: Productions like the original STAR WARS and STAR TREK were relatively low-budget, and were not the juggernaut franchises they later became.
In the case of TREK, we have documentation that there were four hero phasers. Then, because those props were complex/expensive/fragile, came the vacuformed Crapazoids. Those weren’t great, though, so, by the end of the first season came the midgrades: Dummies with less detail than the heroes, which could even be used in the occasional close-up.
Realistically speaking, there probably weren’t many midgrades. At most, maybe 5-7 people would need a phaser on-camera at the same time. And there would also probably be a few backups. I’d guess that no more than a dozen were made. Probably less.
Yet, auction after auction, over the decades.
In the case of STAR WARS, we know there were two Vader sabers, and most likely two Kenobi sabers, not counting the rotating-blade stunts. There’s never been any evidence of more than one Graflex, however, despite its being a more important prop than the other two sabers. Either there was just the one hero—which is a bad idea, in the prop world, since accidents happen, and having backups avoids time and trouble—or the one hero we know was the only one ever used and photographed.
And, more to the point, we’ve only ever had evidence of the live-fire DL-44 hero and the MGC Greedo Killer, the latter of which was thrown together for one insert close-up in post-production. We know there were resin castings of the hero used for the Merr Sonn, etc. but no evidence whatsoever of any other heroes or backups.
There’s never been direct evidence to support the idea of a resin casting being used as a belt-holster version for Harrison Ford. It really seems like the live-fire hero was used both for shooting blanks AND in the holster. Which indicates that there was only one hero, with no backups. Again, not standard procedure on a film set, but it IS possible.
My point is that: A) There are probably a lot fewer of these props floating around out there than people think; B) The most iconic hero props are probably long since gone—disassembled and/or reused in other productions (just as the DL-44 hero Mauser had been before STAR WARS), trashed, lost, or held in private hands.
At the time, STAR WARS was just another schlocky little sci-fi movie everyone thought would fail, or be a modest success at best. The only reason that the Lucasfilm Archives contains as much as it does is because George Lucas is a forward-thinking packrat. Otherwise, most of it would have been sold off, given to Fox for reuse/recycling in other movies, or destroyed.
The real Graflex and DL-44 may show up, someday. I never expected to see the TMOST phaser and Kirk communicator, that’s for sure. Miracles happen.
But Occam’s Razor tells us that pretty much anything which pops up will be a fake. And, in this auction’s case, a very blatant and sloppy fake.