Halliwax's weird V3 theory

I did a little Photos app magic to pull out the neck color in the throne room? I attempted to knock down the green and make the orange/red brighter
FinalDuel_V3_5.jpeg

Screenshot 2024-02-29 at 12.14.28 PM.png
 
Last edited:
A Very Productive Sunday

My Goal Here Is To Make The V3 Hilt, like it would be in ANH. Based on Halliwaxs V3 Theory.

Using a PPP Lineage Cast V3 Stunt
Going to be painted to ANH OBI Motorized Stunt Spec
Missing the Clamp and Accessories
Fitted with a Vintage D Ring.

Got the Hilt Painted in Flat Black in the correct areas. Now I have to paint match the windvane and neck!

I hope Halliwax Approves ;)
IMG_4519.jpeg
 
A Very Productive Sunday

My Goal Here Is To Make The V3 Hilt, like it would be in ANH. Based on Halliwaxs V3 Theory.

Using a PPP Lineage Cast V3 Stunt
Going to be painted to ANH OBI Motorized Stunt Spec
Missing the Clamp and Accessories
Fitted with a Vintage D Ring.

Got the Hilt Painted in Flat Black in the correct areas. Now I have to paint match the windvane and neck!

I hope Halliwax Approves ;)View attachment 1817592
 
Last edited:
Not sure where else to put this but this is a V3 theory thread so I believe it fits here.

DaveP's v2 and v3 run has had me thinking.

From what I understand, it's believed that the V3 on set had an ESB card. Is it possible that it did for the castings of the V3 but something happened to the card afterwards, and it was replaced with a vectorboard, which was then taken from it for the hero?

Interested to hear everyone's thoughts, thanks.
 
Not sure where else to put this but this is a V3 theory thread so I believe it fits here.

DaveP's v2 and v3 run has had me thinking.

From what I understand, it's believed that the V3 on set had an ESB card. Is it possible that it did for the castings of the V3 but something happened to the card afterwards, and it was replaced with a vectorboard, which was then taken from it for the hero?

Interested to hear everyone's thoughts, thanks.
No vector card in the v3
 
I feel like the silver traces on the ESB card would at least be slightly visible from an angle like this? It really does look like the gold goes all the way across

It probably is the ESB type card though..

View attachment 1863553

I speculate that the angle that Hamill is holding the hilt at obscures the smaller silver traces on the card.

But—it is possible that this is a replacement card, installed after filming was underway…anything is possible with these hilts.

Look at how much the V2 details changed, as filming was underway.

It could be “pixilation” that we are seeing, those are some pretty uneven / ratty looking trace lines on this card:

IMG_6323.jpeg
 
That is not the production v3 that is a resin stunt with the ESB board painted

Trust me.. 1000% not the vector
Ah thank you. Didn't know for sure if that was the production v3 or a resin stunt.
I speculate that the angle that Hamill is holding the hilt at obscures the smaller silver traces on the card.

But—it is possible that this is a replacement card, installed after filming was underway…anything is possible with these hilts.

Look at how much the V2 details changed, as filming was underway.

It could be “pixilation” that we are seeing, those are some pretty uneven / ratty looking trace lines on this card:

View attachment 1863557
Yep, I'm absolutely seeing those traces now, just obscured by the angle.
The


The casting of the V3 was taken as filming of ROTJ was underway and clearly shows the ESB style card in the clamp (y)

View attachment 1863554

View attachment 1863556
Good to know. Thanks.

Went back and read through this thread, it's a fun read.
Thank ya'll for answering.
 
Interesting that DaveP chose to go with a Vector for his Production run then

Normally, I'd agree with him. I'm trying hard here to see those traces in that Throne Room scene, I really am.

But then the R2 stunt has an ESB card. Just don't see it making sense to take it out after the cast was done, and then adding in a vector board. But like Dunsel says, anything is possible

Stop Talking Fran Healy GIF by Travis
 
Interesting that DaveP chose to go with a Vector for his Production run then

Normally, I'd agree with him. I'm trying hard here to see those traces in that Throne Room scene, I really am.

But then the R2 stunt has an ESB card. Just don't see it making sense to take it out after the cast was done, and then adding in a vector board. But like Dunsel says, anything is possible

View attachment 1863637

With all due respect, Dunsel is a moron who doesn’t know what he’s talking about and serves no useful purpose.

Oh, wait a minute…

Yes, I stand by my original assessment of Dunsel, as noted above.
 
lol I always thought that "hilt" was a resin one too, its a little wonky, without a discolored lever hinge and some weird blemishes. Also the bottom is solid, so not a hollow R2 stunt

Here are screenshots from that lovely website
Screenshot 2024-09-26 at 8.52.08 PM.png
Screenshot 2024-09-26 at 8.52.19 PM.png
Screenshot 2024-09-26 at 8.53.09 PM.png
 
Back
Top