I gotta back DarkPassenger here. I was one of the members bidding on both of these watch auctions last week and I didn't win either of them. Could it have gone to someone who had no idea what the watch was?...Certainly it could have, but I seriously doubt it.
I had been trying to ID the watch for a long while now and when DarkPassenger offered to tell the other board members here over PM, I sent a PM. It was answered promptly and with a good detailed pic of the watch face and a comparison to a screen shot from the show. He has not withheld anything from anyone, except some new members, and has shared all of his other findings on related threads as well. And he only did that to give established members here who have been searching and following the threads a chance to get one without a bidding war.
If I was a new member trying to ID the watch, I would understand that I can't expect people here to offer up any and all information in a question thats also someone's first post here. I'm not saying thats what happened here and I'm not speaking of anyone in particular, so please no one take any offense. I'm just trying to say that I, for one, understand DarkPassenger's position on the matter and would've accepted it if he hadn't told me what it was and kept looking.
I'm not saying the information should be kept secret. It could have been shared through PM though or at least more discreetly here on the board, even between new and established members so that those who want to know can without the thread turning up in any internet search on the subject that non-members can readily see. I know everyone has different opinions on this and everyone has a right to their own opinion. I'm just sharing mine on this particular situation. Like TymerDC said in a previous post..."cats outta the bag and whatever...let it go man."
I don't think DarkPassenger should be ragged for taking the tact that he did. Everyone knows what the watch is now so lets leave it alone.