Back to the matter of the Hawkins Police Department patch, I recently got one from "smileyproducts13" on Ebay (left).
Here it is compared to the one I've been wearing for a couple years, which I got on Etsy from "dreamworldbybrian" (right).
And below them two screen shots provided by Pinder for comparison.
View attachment 1423736
View attachment 1423739
Seems to me the replica on the left is more accurate overall.
However it has three major problems:
1) the top isn't curved enough
2) the diamond at bottom is far too fat
3) the colours seem off. Yes I know US police "blue" uniforms are extremely dark to the point of appearing black in all but strong sunlight, yet I've taken this patch outdoors and it looks black. And the "gold" is somewhat too orange.
The other patch's colours are off in the opposite ways. A middle ground would be nice.