Are these Star Wars autographs legit?

[jcoffman99]

Hey all,

I have a friend at a charity auction and he sent me this image. Some of the sigs look off to me. I don't want someone to get ripped off as bidding is already up to 1000. Your thoughts?

Thanks,
John

 

[jcoffman99]

Here's the COA

 

[dbuck]

Based on previous charity auctions with that supposed expert certification, I’d say stay far away. Not guaranteeing it’s pure fake like that hero phaser, but odds are not in the buyers favor.

 

[Jay1138]

Those signatures are not good by a longshot. Hopefully you didnt get scammed on a 'charity' piece.

 

[JediMichael]

I must be like the only odd one of the world, as I never cared for autographs. Sure, it makes something worth more, but I more care to display stuff for the item/poster, and having a bunch of writing that you can't even read just makes something look sloppy to me. Guess I'm weird like that. Then theres this issues with buying something already signed and hoping its even real.
If I meet any celebrities, I more care for a picture, but not really a autograph.
While they might not always have a lot of time to stop and chat, I'd rather do that, as it can be more personal, then a quick scribble and thats it.
I remember there was a video of Nicolas Cage "signing autographs" for people. He was more drawing a wavy line on posters, as he was in a rush. Pointless to me.