CSMacLaren
Sr Member
"Anti-Gino crowd" or not, this whitewashes the original issue how?
AA case begins
- Thread starter Jumpin Jax
- Start date
"Anti-Gino crowd" or not, this whitewashes the original issue how?
defstartrooper
Sr Member
+ egotism
Last edited by a moderator:
Qui-Gonzalez
Master Member
The "original issue" was swept under the rug when Brian agreed to let others see them.
CSMacLaren
Sr Member
With regular films, most viewers are happy simply to know the names of the actors and possibly the director. On occasion who the producer is is imporant, or who does the score.
In the case of Star Wars, we have a phenomenon where people want to know every minutiae and who was involved, what parts were used, how a prop was fabricated, etc. In my recent reading of Star Wars Insider, I'm noticing that the magazine is starting to slowly showcase the who's who. I think this is a great move because it gives the SWI a wealth of material to write on.
Last edited by a moderator:
CSMacLaren
Sr Member
Interesting choice of words.
Qui-Gonzalez
Master Member
Oh, please do not play semantics with me, okay? I already agreed with what was said that INITIALLY, posting pics that said "Not to be copied" was bad form. Now it seems that after Brian's approval, you STILL want to beat the dead horse. Sorry, the pictures are very relevant to this thread. So, his agreeing to allow them to be shown here is in good taste. The RPF cares about the pictures as much as the Prop Den does. We also care about Brian Muir's involvement in the prop community at large.
The Den got dibs on the pics, you should be happy.
defstartrooper
Sr Member
where's this third pic then ? i'm just wondering if it's bigger than a postage stamp or doesn't have dirty great watermarks through the thing you actually want to see.
Qui-Gonzalez
Master Member
What third pic? I know what was posted was pretty telling enough for me.
So what you are saying is you are willing to whitewash the fact that this is nothing more than a pile-on of a dead issue to ensure that Gino's actions aren't whitewashed... Thanks for making that clear...
CSMacLaren
Sr Member
I'm not playing semantics whatsoever. "Swept under the rug" was your wording. I just found it interesting. Someone puts Brian in a position where he can't do anything but... and now wrong = right because it's "swept under the rug."
You speak as if I'm possessive on behalf of the Den, and that's playing sematics with me. I'm on various forums. The focal point was that if you twist someone's arm and limit their options, if they chose in favor of your arm twisting, that does not make the arm twisting right.
I think we'd all agree that the pictures are educational and we should credit Mr. Muir for them, but they were not obtained under the best set of circumstances. Let's leave it at that, Gonz.
No more whitewashing, folks.
defstartrooper
Sr Member
Braks said that 3 versions have been made available i've seen 2 the one Brian posted on the propden small and low res.
Another on the TDH source not named a little sharper and bigger but has watermarks right through the actual helmet obscuring it.
Not quite sure what your telling remarks about i know as does everyone it's the base of the final design :rolleyes
Just curious to see a clearer pic is all coz you know i'm interested in SW :thumbsup
Qui-Gonzalez
Master Member
Again, I am with Brak's here. You call it whitewashing, and Muir being "forced". Neither is the case here. Muir could very easily have said "Ya know what, no, I do not want anyone else but the Den to see these images" and that would have been that. There was no forced coercion going on here.
You are making it seem like GINO(And whoever linked the pics to GINO) put Brian under the white light and were beating him with a phone book. Come on, man. People are just as passionate here, and there are many cross posting members on both the Den and here. Is it so far fetched that someone may have asked him AFTER the fact, saying that the RPFers who won't join other forums but are passionate about this case would want to see them as well?
If what is going on is whitewashing, then what you, SL and others are doing is the Prop Den Dawgpile.
The third copy is at the MPPC... (watches the mad dash of the people over to the MPPC). It is between the two sizes and has no watermarks at all.
Bobtherocker
Well-Known Member
When exactly was the last time AA was mentioned in this thread?
Isnt this when AA grabs the attache case full of money and runs while everyone around him is fighting amongst themselves WOAH! there he goes :lol
anybody want to buy some stormtrooper armour? one carefull owner, dubious origins
Isnt this when AA grabs the attache case full of money and runs while everyone around him is fighting amongst themselves WOAH! there he goes :lol
anybody want to buy some stormtrooper armour? one carefull owner, dubious origins
CSMacLaren
Sr Member
Creating categories now? Sorry, I draw the line at politics.
defstartrooper
Sr Member
Thanks i would do but i'm not a member so can't see it
Well if there IS a member there and they want to repost it here... for crying out loud, make SURE you get permission from the president and three boy scouts so you aren't dog piled by.... oh wait... your name isn't Gino... you should be ok or repost at will without repercussion. :thumbsup
Qui-Gonzalez
Master Member
Not categories, just clarity. If you would like to continue to do the dance like this, we can take it to PMs and stop OTing this thread. I know other would appreciate it, as would I.
As to the topic at hand, if the image is only larger, I won't join a forum just to see that.
CSMacLaren
Sr Member
Not categories, just clarity. If you would like to continue to do the dance like this, we can take it to PMs and stop OTing this thread. I know other would appreciate it, as would I.
As to the topic at hand, if the image is only larger, I won't join a forum just to see that.
Clarity? Then you clearly were wrong about associating me and SithLord. The only commonalities are that we both are on the Den and RPF, and we like Vader. In fact, we've argued as well. Many Den members are members of RPF too. So please don't make this an issue between websites.
