Well, it could just be a case of BAD camera angles. I didn't like the look of the JJ-Prise when they first showed pics of it, but after seeing it in action I think it's rather beautiful in it's own way.
To me, these daleks look clunky and funky but I notice that they're all shot from fairly low angles so perhaps better angles will change my opinion.
I'm NOT a fan of the Cushing style bumpers though
never have been and I actually enjoyed those films.
Bad camera angles remind me of a site talking about the "Myspace camera angles" essentially if you shoot a (heavier) girl from a high angle, it tends to reduce the apparent weight by a bit while if you shot a normal person from low angles they tend to look heavier (god knows I do whenever my wife takes my pic)