I was there live for the premier. Costuming/storyline was great the part including the Saracen was the most interesting aspect considering what's happening all over the edges of Europe with the Muslim tribes. The use of religion, having a priest council a Templar into agreeing to have an ally who arent on good terms caught my attention.
I actually like the idea of a predator with a sword. However, if a predator is going to use a sword it should be their only weapon to start with. And the armour set up should be different. Perhaps a helmet representing the black knight etc and so on.
The sword itself was too small, I double hooked tip would of made it look more menacing, the beast is 7 ft 4+ with a small sword that can be held with one hand.... Come on... Give him a claymore (weapon William Wallace used) with two hooks and some width :'D
Loved the use of 'Jinn' (the unseen and the first inhabitants of Earth) something Muslims have had a spiritual war with for centuries something Umar (a disciple of Prophet Muhammad pbuh in Islamic literature) battled a Jinn to victory. So I was expecting a fitting conclusion however the 'deal' simply suggests that the Predator is a creature to be bargained with.
I always viewed predators as honourable, having come to terms with a deal really makes me question the creatures honour and motives. The predator seeks glory as well as death to a worthy opponent.
The ending for me was... meh...
And throughout the film there were cringe-worthy moments where the Templar knights were 'hunting' the predator. They did not look like hunters especially the elf woman. Furthermore, when I studied about the knights there is a certain tactic they had used which was staying together and not separating.
The choreography of the fight scenes needs alot of work they should of watched Hanzo's battle with the Falconer more. Lastly, the worst thing for me was the predators cannon and armour. When you're set to face Knights, why bring high tech weaponry? when relating this back to AVP1 They had the superior weaponary due to their fights with Aliens but I see nothing as harmful as an Alien in the short film. Replace the tri-laser with a cross bow. The beeping bombs with something more old fashion. The only thing that should of been there is the wrist gauntlets and a sword.
That's my opinion

solid B