Pixels
Active Member
Okiedokie.
I can give you 2 screengrabs I have in my folder from doing the crossroads boxes now, I don't know if you actually need these ones but I already have the screenshots so I might as well:

U.S. Wildlife Service (only see Dean's, but Sam's name was Agent Hamil and since Dean's used Dean as his first name, it's a reasonable assumption Sam's ID would say Sam Hamil) put into Dean's crossroads box at the end of season 2. The IDs were originally used in S01E03 Dead in the Water but there's no clear shot of them in that episode.
The photo of Dean is too blurry to be useful but it is an ID from season 1, so if I were recreating it I'd try to use a screenshot or promo pic from season 1 of Dean and Sam for them, cause they're younger and their hair is different.

And the ID Sam puts into a crossroads box S03E05 when he's trying to get Dean out of his deal, Cumberland County Sheriff. Sam's alias is Jimmy Paige, Dean's is Robert Plant according to Aliases I Season Three - Supernatural Wiki
I can go through that and get a shot of Dean's ID too if you want it.
Neither were on your list so I don't know if you wanted those or not. If you want, I can use the alias list on the website I linked and go through the episodes they mention for shots of any IDs used, although I'd hate to be redundant and cover ones you've already done.