Star Trek 2009... I gave it another chance

I watched Star Trek 2009 again when it was on FX a few times. I don't want to write another paper like I did for TRON Legacy but the new Star Trek has a few big problems that can't be excused. I noticed them originally and again recently. I can't look past them and any fan of the originals shouldn't let them slide either.

Luckily this is the origin of an alternate Star Trek crew. So, it really doesn't matter.
 
For the record Noeland is a friend whom I've known for several years. He can "damn" me if he wants. :lol

I'm starting to agree with him. :facepalm



Kevin
 
Yes. I'm just kidding around. I knew Kevin would get it!

Jeyl, I enjoy a lot of your posts and points and opinions. I was not trying to be mean.

I understand the angst over the film. But I did like it.
 
Which still applies to my example, since the enterprise never became energy while travelling faster than light when slingshotting around the sun.



That was more of an easter egg, than a factoid in the film...Besides, we already know that lifespans are much longer in the ST universe due to advanced medical science.
Besides, dont even know if it was the same Archer from the Enterprise series.



We dont know why they werent able to evacuate, so there's no point in assuming it would have been as simple as hopping in their ships an leaving.
likewise, Klingon's have pretty advanced technology, so they should have had some idea that their mining would have resulted in catastrophic effect on Praxis, but that didnt prevent it from being blown apart in Star Trek 6.




Yes, its alos loosely and partially based on a real theory called the Penrose Process.
Warp cores also consist of Anti matter. If Antimatter is introduced to a black hole's event horizon it could theoretically have the opposite effect of matter (anti gravity) which would repel an object....However this effect remains unknown in real world science but still makes it a valid candidate for use in a science fiction.

The theory of lightspeed as far as we've gone is that tachyon particles DO become energy but revert back to their original mass once slowed down. So if in the future there is a way to achieve lightspeed, the Enterprise has the ability to become an energy beam while traveling at 186000 mi/sec.

Penrose Process - sounds interesting - would this have been theorized by Roger Penrose

As for the rest I can tell you like the movie - where I don't. Doesn't matter. But chalking up something a character said as an easter egg - Archer having a beagle -- C'mon - we know who they are talking about.
 
Back
Top