I can't say I really grew up on George Reeves (he was dead long before I was born), I definitely fit the Chris Reeve era age-wise.
My perfect movie Superman hasn't been filmed yet. If the could just film the mid to late 80's comics (I've already mentioned John Byrne's Man of Steel).
Now you know what happens if we film Byrne's Superman --- that means no Superboy!!!?! And that leads to a problem with the Legion of Superheroes, pocket universes and all that mess finally leading up to a Zero Hour film. What a mess.
I did LOVE Byrne's take on the whole thing - especially Krypton.