Richard Baker
Sr Member
I really liked Capaldi but there were only a couple of shows that really worked well for me- he seemed to be a designated taxi driver for Clara to have adventures with. She was the first companion I remember who had a primary life she did not give up to travel- she kept her job and social life and just went out for fun. Others did keep a home connection but when they chose to leave with the Doctor they left. Danny Pink was a horrible addition to e show and ruined every scene he appeared in.
Jodi does a pretty good Doctor- reminds me a lot of David Tennant in style and delivery. I have four issues with her shows though.
1- Far too many companions. The show runners tried to broaden the cast with new demographics for viewers to identify with- that is the reason they gave in an interview. The trouble is trying to find something for all of them to do in an episode. If Yasmin is supposed to be a member of the police, even a rookie, she brings none of that to the table- it just seems to be a random back story pulled from a hat. Ryan does more harm that good- he even decided on his own, to send another time traveler, who is a known meddler, back into the past where he could cause more problems to the time line. Graham seems to be the only one that is contributing in a meaningful way instead of causing needles complications. Dump the other two, keep him and move on.
2- Lackluster stories which seem to be based on virtue signalling- the monsters in this past season were mostly humans acting badly as an example for us. I would like some traditional Dr Who stories and stop being lectured at.
3- Worst TARDIS interior ever. They went from a grand showcase of alien technology, with sweeping stairs and nooks and crannies filled with books and tech, to salt lamp fingers inside a soccer ball. If this was an alien ship for a single episode it could pass, but this is the first TARDIS I do not want to even visit. I saw a number of proposed designs before the big reveal- all of them were better that this one.
4- Cut back on the magnificent production values with location shooting and give us more stories with the money you saved. The classic series managed to produce some very good work on a shoestring budget because they focused on telling us a good story. This newest incarnation seems to be obsessed on being as visually overwhelming and the stories are just an excuse for the next feast for the eyes. I do not mean they have to go back to cardboard sets and paper mache creatures, but strike a balance. Not every episode has to try and outdo the Avengers or Game of Thrones, but use the SFX to add spice, not be the main course.
I still watch the show (my daughter loves it), but I find myself having to push through an episode instead of enjoying it. The first season with a new Doctor is always a bit rough, but this new show has a lot of issues in concept which are fundamental.
Jodi does a pretty good Doctor- reminds me a lot of David Tennant in style and delivery. I have four issues with her shows though.
1- Far too many companions. The show runners tried to broaden the cast with new demographics for viewers to identify with- that is the reason they gave in an interview. The trouble is trying to find something for all of them to do in an episode. If Yasmin is supposed to be a member of the police, even a rookie, she brings none of that to the table- it just seems to be a random back story pulled from a hat. Ryan does more harm that good- he even decided on his own, to send another time traveler, who is a known meddler, back into the past where he could cause more problems to the time line. Graham seems to be the only one that is contributing in a meaningful way instead of causing needles complications. Dump the other two, keep him and move on.
2- Lackluster stories which seem to be based on virtue signalling- the monsters in this past season were mostly humans acting badly as an example for us. I would like some traditional Dr Who stories and stop being lectured at.
3- Worst TARDIS interior ever. They went from a grand showcase of alien technology, with sweeping stairs and nooks and crannies filled with books and tech, to salt lamp fingers inside a soccer ball. If this was an alien ship for a single episode it could pass, but this is the first TARDIS I do not want to even visit. I saw a number of proposed designs before the big reveal- all of them were better that this one.
4- Cut back on the magnificent production values with location shooting and give us more stories with the money you saved. The classic series managed to produce some very good work on a shoestring budget because they focused on telling us a good story. This newest incarnation seems to be obsessed on being as visually overwhelming and the stories are just an excuse for the next feast for the eyes. I do not mean they have to go back to cardboard sets and paper mache creatures, but strike a balance. Not every episode has to try and outdo the Avengers or Game of Thrones, but use the SFX to add spice, not be the main course.
I still watch the show (my daughter loves it), but I find myself having to push through an episode instead of enjoying it. The first season with a new Doctor is always a bit rough, but this new show has a lot of issues in concept which are fundamental.