Any Zenbot CNC users here

I own a Fireball V90. Its all MDF and Resin in the construction. There are a lot of good metal components on the machine like the shafts and screws. However, look at the price. $599 for the base kit, you add on the motors and electronics and you are at $1100. Add on your router and your mount and you are at $1300. I added more things on and got to about $1800 once I had the machine that I wanted. (I think overall with the computer and dust enclosure I spent $2500 on a Fireball V90.)

Looking at the Zenbot, and you have something that is much different from the Fireball. The Zenbot doesn't use traditional round shafts. It uses steel square tube at a 45 degree angle and uses rollerblade bearings to ride on that square steel. Instead of using an ACME threaded rod or ball screws, it uses a timing belt. This makes the machine much much faster. However the motors are smaller in power.

In order to price out a comparable machine between the Zenbot and the Fireball, you would need to spend upwards of $1200 (and then the Zenbot would still be smaller). Also looking at the elctronics for the Zenbot, they use a small voltage and small amperage power supply where the Fireball can get you up to 3amps per motor and 40 volts.

Basically the Fireball wins out in terms of power and using expensive accurate components. The only thing the Zenbot has going for itself is the HDPE construction, it definitely uses cheap components otherwise.

It might be worth investigating in an even cheaper third candidate which has a blend of Zenbot, and Fireball's features. Who knows, maybe that third candidate will offer upgrades to HDPE after listening to customer suggestions. ;)
 
Thanks for the reply.

I hear ya on the motors/components..

But could you upgrade the motors on the Zen and use a different controller box?


For me the fireball also suffers from only having one table size.

What is up with those giant pipes on the side?
 
I hear ya on the motors/components..

But could you upgrade the motors on the Zen and use a different controller box?

You could, although the belts might not be able to handle the larger motors. Control boxes can be bought from other places, but you could have the problem of them not being plug and play.

For me the fireball also suffers from only having one table size.

I agree. They are working on a $3000 aluminum 24" x 24" model. But I am not sure if that is ever going to happen. The thing that bothers me with like the Zenbot is, what if you buy the small version and wanted to go up to the next size? You'd have to buy a whole new machine.

To put in a little bit of a plug for my machine.. I designed a 18" x 12" x 4" version and a 24" x 18" x 4" version. The smaller version is what is for sale on Kickstarter, and the larger version will be available hopefully this Summer should things go well. The larger version will re-use a lot of parts from the smaller version should someone want to upgrade for cheaper than buying a whole new machine!

What is up with those giant pipes on the side?

They are what hold the machine apart. It actually is a really smart design, but it takes up so much space! The Zenbot, or my designs seem to take up the least amount of space while maximizing cutting area.
 
Back
Top