CharlesHouse
Active Member
The whole Paul Dini concept was that love isn't always healthy, and it certainly wasn't/isn't for Harley in those early days. New 52 actually has Harley off on her own, with non abusive relationships and is actively doing some good in the world as an anti-hero rather than an anti-villain. I think the idea of the second type is more appealing, but of course I still love the idea of the original Harley.
Psychologically it would be interesting to see the pure dedication/blind love (mad love) angle, but I think I can accept the newer style if it's done well. (Bloody hope it is!)
I appreciate the change in theory, but there are many issues in practice, particularly with Conner and Palmiotti writing. Harley was on her own for years in her 2000 series and after, prior to 2011. That said, most people knew she would eventually return to the Joker, which she also has done in New 52 and will after. It doesn't sway from Dini, it tries to have it's cake and eat it by varying without committing. Dini's character means a lot to people who have been abused in relationships.