Star Trek: Questions you always wanted answers to

I’m actually gonna have to rewatch Picard season 3 … did they even mention B4

Having no idea this was a thing, I prob just thought it was weird dialogue if he was mentioned
Late reply but I’m just rewatching all of pivard

They do mention him in the first season… don’t remember the context - it’s really hard to watch the first two… just really bad

BUT, if you do watch the first two, it makes the third soooo much better. Just constantly thinking “how did they get it so wrong and turn it around like this!?”

And I’m coming from a pov of just watching all the not so great next gen movies…

In season 3 Picard the data they find was a new one with Lor, and Data inside…
 
In season 3 Picard the data they find was a new one with Lor, and Data inside…

True, and the new Data also has Lal and B4, although they are only mentioned.

As someone who hated S1, skipped S2 because it seemed even worse, I have watched S3 FOUR TIMES! It is a love letter to TNG fans, and in some ways an 8th season of TNG in itself.

THIS is how you handle legacy AND introduce new characters to love.

And it's a shame we're getting Section 31 and Starfleet Academy, and not Legacy. Trek took a left turn again after Picard S3.
 
Am I the only one who thought that Riker came off as an arrogant / inflexible / coddled / spoiled / disrespectful officer in this episode?

I'm with Riker, Jellico (apt name) was an arrogant rectum. He knew full well that his position on the Enterprise was temporary, but he acted like he owned it. When you're house sitting for a friend you don't take it upon yourself to rearrange their furniture and switch their internet providers.
 
I'm with Riker, Jellico (apt name) was an arrogant rectum. He knew full well that his position on the Enterprise was temporary, but he acted like he owned it. When you're house sitting for a friend you don't take it upon yourself to rearrange their furniture and switch their internet providers.

I’m on Team Jellico on this one ;) it was his ship to command.
 
It was, but he now knows that commanding grudging respect in your crew and forcing everyone into your own style makes for a very mediocre career.

The man is a legend…to the point that he now has his own action figure.

Relive the excitement of everyone’s favorite Starfleet contrarian by ordering subordinate action figures to change their scheduled duty shifts and wear a proper uniform.

“Make it so” you say?? Nah…”Get-It-Done!” says Captain Jellico!

IMG_6851.jpeg


;)
 
my star trek question I've always wanted answered-
I've heard talk that TOS rank braids were left overs from the first 10 Commandments movie. Can anyone show a screen cap or BTS pictures of said braids ? Or is there another version of where they came from?
 
In Star Trek: The Motion Picture Kirk says that he has been head of Starfleet something-or-other for 3 and a half years. The Enterprise has been in drydock or 18 months. So, who was the captain for those other two years before the refit? Was it Decker? For some reason I always assumed the V'ger mission was to be his first time in the captain's chair. Was he the captain all that time? If so, I guess I can imagine why he was so ticked off. I never really thought about it until now.

Regardless, that would be two years of OS Enterprise missions with some of the original crew. I'm not sure when Spock and McCoy left the Enterprise, but obviously Sulu, Uhura, Chekov, and Scottie stayed around.

Have any of those missions ever been spoken of? Maybe in the books or something, maybe?
 
In Star Trek: The Motion Picture Kirk says that he has been head of Starfleet something-or-other for 3 and a half years. The Enterprise has been in drydock or 18 months. So, who was the captain for those other two years before the refit? Was it Decker? For some reason I always assumed the V'ger mission was to be his first time in the captain's chair. Was he the captain all that time? If so, I guess I can imagine why he was so ticked off. I never really thought about it until now.

Regardless, that would be two years of OS Enterprise missions with some of the original crew. I'm not sure when Spock and McCoy left the Enterprise, but obviously Sulu, Uhura, Chekov, and Scottie stayed around.

Have any of those missions ever been spoken of? Maybe in the books or something, maybe?

I believe that Scotty was referring to the total amount of time the refit operation was actively underway. I assume the Enterprsie was drydocked during the end of the 5 year mission and the the beginning of the refit operation.
 
In Star Trek: The Motion Picture Kirk says that he has been head of Starfleet something-or-other for 3 and a half years. The Enterprise has been in drydock or 18 months.

Two and a half years, not 3.5. So there is one year after Kirk leaves before "eighteen months redesigning and refitting the Enterprise" I guess it took a year for Starfleet to decide she should be refit at all. Perhaps treaty negotiations with the Klingons left the decision in limbo.
 
I rewatched Generations for maybe the 6th time. Is there any chance that the Klingons or Soran had something to do with Picard's nephew and brother dying in a fire? It may be nothing, but something in the dialogue with Guinan made me think maybe they could have done it to get Picard to search for the Nexus.
 
In Star Trek: The Motion Picture Kirk says that he has been head of Starfleet something-or-other for 3 and a half years. The Enterprise has been in drydock or 18 months. So, who was the captain for those other two years before the refit? Was it Decker? For some reason I always assumed the V'ger mission was to be his first time in the captain's chair. Was he the captain all that time? If so, I guess I can imagine why he was so ticked off. I never really thought about it until now.

Regardless, that would be two years of OS Enterprise missions with some of the original crew. I'm not sure when Spock and McCoy left the Enterprise, but obviously Sulu, Uhura, Chekov, and Scottie stayed around.

Have any of those missions ever been spoken of? Maybe in the books or something, maybe?
My guess would be that for most of those 3 years the Enterprise didn't have a Captain since there wouldn't be any crew serving aboard her while she was undergoing a major refit. Decker probably only assumed command shortly before the events of TMP when the Enterprise's refit was nearing completion and she started to take on crew.
 
I'm thinking Decker knew far too much about the refit to have only signed on recently.

  • "This is a totally new Enterprise, you don't know her a tenth as well as I do."
  • Decker identified a faulty module in Engineering right before Kirk pulled him aside.
  • Decker knew that the phasers were cut off during an antimatter imbalance.
  • His casual style with Scotty and taking ownership: "She'll launch even if we have to drag her out with our bare hands, right Scotty?"
No, I think Decker was there from the beginning.

Also, I'm pretty sure Kirk was desk surfing for two and a half years, not three.
 
I think Decker was assigned as Captain as soon as Kirk left to be an Admiral. He wouldn't have much traditional crew under him. He would probably be in command of all the engineers working on the Refit project, with Scotty at the top of that list.
 
Enterprise could easily been out of service for the period between ending the 5-year mission and the start of the refit.
 
Has anyone ever wonder why a Starfleet ship never uses their transporter as a tactical defense against boarding parties?
 
In the same vein as the Star Wars thread with the same/similar name, what questions about Star Trek (all incarnations) do you have questions about and would like answered? For me, it's what does an Ops officer actually do on a starship that requires them to have a station on the bridge of the starship and, in the case of the Enterprise D & E, in the front next to the helmsman? According to the Enterprise (TNG) Tech Manual the Ops officer's job is described as being what an operations officer should do, coordinating all of the operations on a ship, routing all requests for assets, time on sensors, in labs, and I'm guess duty shifts, etc. yet on TNG and Voyager we never see them doing any of that, they always seem to act as everything but ops, more often than not they seem to act as science officer, or comms officer, a duty they seem to share with the helmsman and security officer.

Another question I have about TNG & Voyager, where do all of those spare crewmembers come from and go to whenever the senior officers are summoned to the bridge or when they are tasked to leave the bridge for whatever reason before the end of their shift? Do they have a ready room of sorts just off of the bridge where they sit during their shift and wait until one of the senior bridge crew leaves when they have to go on an away mission or have to check out something elsewhere on the ship? Likewise, when the senior officers are off duty but are called up (something that seems to happen fairly often on Voyager) do these people go to the same ready room, or do their shift officially end whenever they're replaced by the senior officers, or do they actually have secondary stations or duties?
I would assume that they do all go to a ready room, but hey, who knows? Maybe it's "free time" for them and they all meet at the bar! LOL JK.
 
Here's a question I would like answered. Why was Voyager the only ship where the Captain didn't have a center seat on the bridge? Every bridge design leaves little to no doubt as to where the person in charge sits. On Voyager, you have to ask 'which side?'.
Hmmmm, you are right. Never thought about that. Good question indeed!
 
Yes you still need weapons, but not as strong as an offensive ship. You sneak up cloaked to a un shielded ship, decloak and fire.

On other hand, i always thought cloaking a ship doesnt fit into the klingon way. As proud warriors it is kinda lame of sneaking up, uncloak, shoot, cloak and hide isnt it?
Aaahh, but are they indeed proud warriors or just sneaky cowards underneath all of the bravado? I've seen episodes where you can feel the fear in some of them when they are caught and held under threat of death by the Federation. They say "Kill me!", but their eyes say, "Don't do it!!" LOL
 
I know the answer is ‘budgets and time’, but why were so few of the original Enterprises missions actually seeking out strange new worlds. Mostly it was visiting already existing colonies, supply run, medical help etc. Boldly going where someone had already gone before.
 
Back
Top