Sarednab's Book of Secrets recast of Marsattack's version?

Status
Not open for further replies.
First of all, thanks to all people that trust in me!
Second, mars you are a liar! I can say that in public! You said that I "change" name of thread n "Revised Book of Secrets" but this WAS THE ORIGINAL NAME!
We always wrote revised cause the text of the book was from the old book made by 2 (not 1!) person.
We talked so much in private and you said me there wasn't problem to use it (remember that were another person that wrote story!!!), the important is that I write in thread that book contains text from the other (modified and added much more text). This is what you said me! And I do it!!! In every post!!!! This can be confirmed by all people that follow my old thread! I ask to mod if this thread is still in their archive to activate it, so all people can know the story!
After you seen my works you back to me (after I work for 2 years, YES!!!! Maybe you can't believe in this but you don't know my work on it!!!!!!)! I don't know the reason, maybe cause you was jelous of my work?!?

Remember only last thing, I don't NEED to recast work of noone. I have the right skill to made all by myself! I don't need your help or your works to made a prop!
You back to me after 3 years and tell to people that I am a recaster!!???? If I was mod in this board, I ban you in a second!
 
Sarednab now you calling me a liar ???
The first thread of yours said ultimate book!!!
You were asked to change it.
You stated later after the mods that he stories were he same not at the start of your original thread!!
Although now you state that the book is the same , this was my point.
I only asked Tom to remove marks work, he needed to know why I was saying that so I said enough for him to remove .
He openend the thread and not me.
I only agreed to some things and this was only AFter you got questioned by mods.
I know you added more stuff to the book and more inserts , all I cared at the time was the way you were presenting it.
 
So you are saying Sarednab was saying that it was completely his own work, and only after the mods got involved did he change the listing to a revised version?

If he got permission from the original runs source to use the original runs contents, then I don't see the problem. The only problem would be him falsely advertising the book as his own work, for which he changed when told to.

Soooo... What's the recasting accusation for?
 
I just saw this thread...so thought I had better chime in.

For starters...this issue was already laid to bed some time ago. To the point that even the MODs were involved. It seems to raise its head every time the Bos is mentioned lol

One way or another Marsattack becomes agitated for perceived wrongs he suffered in what he calls our "partnership."

Here's the skinny.

Mars agreed to put up most if not all the initial costs to make the prototype. He thought it a good idea and believed I had the skill to pull off my side of the work.
My contribution was that I spent 11 months of my time and wrote a good 97% of the BoS apart from screen seen pages. I also garnered not only most of the artwork and inserts through research and contacts but permission from a few forum celebrities I approached to contribute some of their work as inserts. Two of whom are well known artists.

Fast forward to the run happening.....people are happy. Mars and I are slapping each other on the back and all is good.

Next scene: I relate to Marsattack on the phone one day (We live in different states, the BOS was created via email, phone-calls and post) that I have made a great deal to secure myself a sideshow endoskull for $300 which the owner agreed to let me pay off over some months. At the time I was an industrial cleaner and didn't make that big a salary.

Mars is secretly insulted that I am doing this and not helping him foot the BoS costs (needless to say he's buying a set of metal aliens marine armour at the time) even though we had an agreement over the funding etc Plus the run is at this time paying for itself and I pushed that his costs be covered before we even start dipping into the trade pool or sharing any profit lol

Final scene weeks later, I am at work at a remote location with terrible phone signal. Mars has tried to call me quite a few times and when I can't hear him or connect properly he explodes!!! Accusing me of using him, playing games and buying my own toys and letting him do all the work and pay all the costs.

Needless to say I tried to explain I wasn't playing a game or being silly but Marcel was so paranoid and angry about his unresolved (and to that point) unspoken issues with me I couldn't even talk sense to him. The relationship degenerated to the point he started threatening me and stated that he was going to the mods and that I was a thief. Stealing his work. I was incredulous and actually quite hurt by his behaviour which continued to get worse and worse.

From that point I publically severed our relationship and our so called friendship. Sad but true. I also stated he couldn't use any of my work outside the original run. I was pretty angry at this stage.

Since then Ive been through various pm wars with Marcel. At one point I was even at risk of being banned until it was shown through a third party that Marcel did in fact release any claim to any "possible" work he contributed irrespective of "ownership."

In our original agreement I was promised my own copy of a BoS from Marcel during our run. I never got this. He said I would have to "buy" one. I also sent him a lot of inserts from various sources which he borrowed but has kept. I write that off to his payback mentality.

Since I never even got a copy of my own work my friend Sarednab and I decided to work together and create an even better, more accurate version. Needless to say he started to get the end of the boot from Marcel as well when this became public.

I will say it finally and publically now. I wrote the BoS.
He would continually tell me he would write something but in the end never produced anything useable as he was too busy with the "cover" or work. Which I was cool with. He even approached various folk to write his contribution for him to no success. I ended up writing the few entries he committed himself to write. I was the writer he was the launchpad.

I certainly compliment him on his work ethic for what he did do and his willingness to take a gamble on my skill as an amateur author. Our friendship didn't survive this project. :(

The only reason he had a leg to stand on in all this is because I was nice enough to compliment him as a full partner in threads.

When it comes right down to it, I learnt a lot dealing with Mars.

But my relationship on this with Sarednab is both fair and equitable. As soon as he finished his work on our digital files he sent me a full copy. He is honest and transparent. Even though I feel I wrote the BOS (because I did) and included Marsattack in the credit it seems he has just as much right to claim ownership of making a BOS I guess...But that other side though is that he gave permission for anything that "may" have been his to be used. Story over. The he said she said debate is therefore over who did what is really moot.

Funnily enough, after I told him to stop writing me insulting pm's and emails later on down the track he contacted me to purchase a HIC from me. Go figure lol

I know you have a different take on things Marcel, but this is how "I" really think things went and no amount of your browbeating and bullying is going to change that. Leave other people alone and stop sending PM's, leave people alone, especially those who have purchased the BOS.

You need to move on Marcel. Insulting and accusing us isn't going to win your battle. The war is over.

T
A
Z

Sent from my iPhone lol



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free
 
Last edited:
First of all: Taz, thanks a lot for your view on things. Your version of the story would certainly explain why marsattack tried to settle things through PM and not in public.

Secondly, marsattack:
Sarednab now you calling me a liar ???
The first thread of yours said ultimate book!!!
You were asked to change it.
What the h*ll does it matter how the book is called? Do you really think I, or any other of the buyers wouldn't have bought it if it wasn't called "Ultimate Book"? In my case (and I guess I'm not alone) I subscribed to the list because I really like journals and books as props, so this one was on my wish list, and secondly, because I had great experiences with Sarednab in the past, and was sure he would deliver an awesome prop. Even if it was called "Yet another Book of Secrets", I would have bought it.

I only asked Tom to remove marks work, he needed to know why I was saying that so I said enough for him to remove . He openend the thread and not me.
Not true, mate. You not ONLY asked me to remove things. You ALSO accused Sarednab of recasting in the first PM you sent me. One of the sentences in that first PM:
You own nothing more than a recasted book with extra inserts that make absolutely no sense to the book!
After I told you I had my doubts about your claim and asked why you let the sales thread in 2011 just go one then, and why Sarednab wasn't banned if he was a recaster, you came up with all kind of stories. And THAT is why I opened this thread: to get a clear view on things.

I can't help but feel that Taz's story will come closest to the truth: You and Taz made up the stories for the first Book, something went wrong there and Taz took his stories to another partner to create a second BoS, which you didn't like. You said the stories of Taz belong to a partnership, not to a person. Well, if you don't have that on contract it's your word against TazVader's. And you should know that in this business intellectual property is "by default" for the creator. You can't just "assume" that Taz his stories don't belong to him alone, just because they initially were meant to be used in your BoS? I really don't see why Taz does not have the right to do with his creations what he wants?

As for the inserts: you accuse Sarednab and Taz to come up with the same pictures FROM THE PUBLIC DOMAIN in their BoS??? What's that all about! Off course they come up with the same pictures!!! If you write about the Kennedy Murder, there are only a few famous pictures that pop up. You don't own the right on a picture from the public domain, just because you used it first. That's ridiculous. I posted a list of all the inserts in Sarednab's and Taz BoS. Most of the things there are pictures / documents that can be found on the internet. Apart from that, you also mentioned you gave your permission to use some of your inserts.

Anyway, things get clear to me after Taz's explanation. It's clear that marsattack wasn't happy with the second BoS, but recasting? Don't really think so (didn't see any proof yet). I think we might better close this thread. Everybody has done their story, in public this time, so indeed. I think it's time to leave this matter alone. Marsattack, maybe it's also good not to contact people who have nothing to do with this (and only bought a BoS) through PM anymore.
 
The reality of the books is quite more extensive than it's being presented here.
Not all the events are being mentioned in Christians post and there is a lot missing.
This is a the three year old topic which was kept completely to pms .
It had been laid to rest .
Christian you have your opinion and I have mine that is why it didn't work between us.
I am happy to move on as this thread will never get anywhere.
Marcel
 
The reality of the books is quite more extensive than it's being presented here.
Not all the events are being mentioned in Christians post and there is a lot missing.
This is a the three year old topic which was kept completely to pms .
It had been laid to rest .
It had been laid to rest, but you STILL contact me (who has nothing to do with all this, but only bought a BoS) through PM to accuse Sarednab from recasting?
Christian you have your opinion and I have mine that is why it didn't work between us.
I am happy to move on as this thread will never get anywhere.
Marcel
OK, but also stop PM-ing RPF members then, to dig this up over and over again. If you really want to move one, you just don't talk about it anymore. PM-ing me because I only stated I would measure the size of my BoS to help out a fellow RPF-member, is not a sign of "moving on" or "let it rest".

I hope you realize that the first PM you have sent me was totally unnecessary and probably achieved the opposite of what you wanted. Not my fault, mate. You secretly wanted to throw a rock, it came back in to your face in public. Move on now...
 
As mentioned, this issue was dealt with previously and does not need to be rehashed. Thread closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top