Any problems I should be aware of that occur with alginate as opposed to silcone?
I've been casting urethane for about 19 years. Here's an encapsulation of what I know...
Many years ago I was tasked with creating a game controller prototype from the foam concept model we had. I loved alginate (for pulling lifecasts, etc.) and I loved TAP Plastics Quik-Cast polyurethane resin, and I had plenty of both on hand. However, I had never used them
together before. I needed to preserve the foam model, so the alginate was perfect. The controller needed to be strong and have internals mounted, so the Quik Cast was perfect.
Two great tastes that go great together, right? Right?!?!
Well, I didn't want to ruin our solitary foam model, so I did a test pull from an older foam model and quik-cast a test model. Unfortunately for me, it turned out perfectly. An absolutely beautiful model.
I showed my proof-of-concept model to the boss and got the green light for the real deal. That's when I nearly went mad because no matter what I did, I couldn't reproduce my initial success. Every cast was a disaster. I changed everything,
everything I could think of...except the alginate/polyurethane combo. :sick
So, 24 hate-filled, sleepless hours later, I ended up hand grinding the shape out of bondo-covered abomination.
Bottom line: I wish I had been as smart as you and asked someone before I tried it. Unfortunately, the RPF didn't exist yet...
- JD
Edit: Whoa, I didn't realize the original post was years old. Oh well, maybe these new replies will help someone avoid this particular problem!