Just a few points on the above issues:
1. I sent jhaha some pictures of monsters' quibbler, and I told him not to post images of it anywhere. I didn't think monsters was making the quibbler anymore, and there was no other way to get it-jhadha told me he just wanted it for his personal collection only. monsters told me he wasn't printing anymore and that mine was an exception. if anymore were printed that would be dishonest to those who bought them.
2. monsters claims he can't share his references, but there arn't any others availble online, so he is effectivley claiming onership on the prop (unless the person he got the references from told him not to share them?). a good picture of one page of the replica is on the junkyard thread for everyone to see, with no watermarks or anything.
3. Jhadha has shared a lot of great props of his own making, filling a big gap for free Daily prophets and quibblers. although, he hasn't always obeyed the rule of no watermarks/no previews of paid items.
4. I don't approve of monster's attitude, ecpesalliy on a public thread like this. I think jhadha just found the images and is using them as references to make his own.
5. with props as accurate as these, it is hard to tell one replica from another, or replicas from offical images. there have been misunderstandings over this sort of thing before.
6. I have seen ecl's beedle the bard cover on HP wiki (with a file name along the lines of "beedlebardecl") so it does happen. people not even realise it's not an official image!
7. jhadha has listed items for sale on deviant art before, and either dosn't understand the "prints" thing there, or is denying selling the items. don't forget that engllish is not Jhadha's native laungage.
8. Jhadha has been a victim too... people have reposted his art as their own, I've reported a member for this recently.
sorry for such a long post, just getting my opinons out there.
now everyone please settle down and issues off-thread!