Just my opinion but I think there are at least 5 jackets associated with Fight Club. Some may be used for photo shoots, screen used, prototype etc. I will show why below...
I am almost certain that x-marts jacket was not seen on screen but that doesn't change the fact that it may be the original that Kaplan distressed and used to have his apprentices replicate for the movie... who knows. In my opinion I still think it is one of TWO that I would die to have or see (Rupe you are so lucky!!!) The collar of this jacket has the texture it has because of the leathers location on the animal while it was alive. This type of leather is usually the armpit (or similar) of the animal. My JAL has this on the underside of the collar. I'll try and get some photos. Also, the reason Toms replica from a few pages back is so accurate is because he had the original in hand at the time and had a replica made.
The differences between the jackets are primarily noticeable in the sleeves and the collar (not color or shine, that is paint)
Anyone with leather jacket experience know that a leather jacket can’t rest, hang, fold differently (back and forth)
Jackets:
1. X-Marts and Toms Jacket
2. Fox Studios Display Jacket (Notice: Loose stitch at the pocket, collar rolls open really low, wrinkles on the right arm)
3. Jacket Seen on Brad during filming. (Notice: No loose stitch, collar is creased and the crease is higher, wrinkles on arm)
4. Jacket only seen in this magazine cover photo shoot (Notice aging at shoulders, dimpling at the stitches, and collar is creased even higher)
5: Jacket seen with Kaplan. (Notice: No wrinkles on the arm)
Thoughts?