I was fifteen and my father had bought us all opening night tickets weeks in advance. We all discussed it afterwards, a poor mishmash of a couple of TOS episodes was the prevailing opinion.
There was good, the music, the Enterprise, seeing the crew back together, some odd bits here and there. The bad, which we all know, bloated and boring, scans interpreted as attacks, even the usage of au, the cloud is 82 au's, which I doubt one in a hundred people know. I did, but I can't remember why I knew it and thought that was a ridiculous size. I remember leaning over and telling my dad what that meant and he made a scrunchy face like he thought it ridiculous as well. Sometimes had a hard time understanding Persis once she was a probe, which needed to happen as quickly as possible based on her acting skills.
You could tell it was rushed, but I still had a bit of fondness for it despite its many flaws and lack of action.
I bought the lit enterprise model and loved it, the pack of blueprints, books, comics, action figures, etc.
I also wanted it to succeed as we needed a sequel. A proper sequel. Thankfully........
I will say the directors cut is an improvement. I long ago heard that a blu-ray of the cut may not happen as the effects were rendered in 480 and they'd have to be redone for a blu.