1) This quote of yours literally says that Palpatine's origin would have made the OT convoluted. Post 2201. Did you forget your own posts?
No, it's just that, as usual, you're disregarding important context and kind of missing the point of what's being said. Such as the last time you tried to pick my post apart and ended up conflating four columns of data into two, and then having the audacity to complain that I was the one who had the math wrong.
Maybe my wording was unclear. If that's the case, let me try to explain again and reiterate what I said in post #2240. TLJ has a plot that Rian wants the audience to follow, just as ESB does. The telling of the narrative of TLJ requires the audience to know NOTHING about Snoke's backstory. It's not relevant to the space chase. It's not relevant to Rey's interactions with Luke (e.g. the "Leia blames Snoke" line I pointed out earlier). It's not relevant to Canto Bight, it's not relevant to Rose.
And yes, maybe TLJ would have been more satisfying if they had thrown a line that gives the audience
something. I get that criticism, and as I said, that's totally valid.
But it doesn't change the fact that Snoke's backstory isn't the thing that's moving the action forward. It's just not.
Likewise with ESB, what you initially replied with was this:
@
jlee562
If you can argue that knowing the Emperors background would have made ANH or the OT convoluted, then I can certainly argue that TLJ is convoluted and show how they could have reduced that issue.
No, my argument literally makes no claim about inserting the Emperor's background into anything else but ESB. Not ANH, not the OT as a whole. I'm saying that it's not important to the narrative of the individual film.
2) And this is a TLJ topic, I can draw comparison to TLJ at any time. That is not predicated on your preferences or necessarily even directed wholly at you.
Fair enough, but perhaps you should find space to do that when you're not quoting my posts or tagging me in your posts. It sure makes it seem like your comments are directed at me.