Page 2 of 12 FirstFirst 1234567 ... LastLast
Subscribe
  1. Member Since
    Apr 2001
    Messages
    519
    Jan 15, 2017, 12:39 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #26

    This is really great! I haven't built a saber in at least 10 years, and I yet am still finding it really fun just for pleasure reading.

    That being said – is there an error in the second paragraph of the page with you first start to discuss the Skywalker hero lightsaber in ESB? I could be misreading it but it seems to contradict itself. Sorry I can't seem to cut and paste the exact language from the PDF – but the second sentence says that the ESB Production seemed to have acquired their flashes from a "supply that was made later than the original." But then the very next sentence states that "these versions pre-date the ones used in ANH". So it seems to say that the flashes used in ESB were made later then those used in ANH – but it also seems to go on to say that the ones used in ESB were made first. Am I just misunderstanding what is written here?


    In any event – great job and thanks again!

    M
  2. matty matt's Avatar
    Member Since
    Feb 2014
    Messages
    1,490
    Jan 15, 2017, 1:25 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #27

    It really looks great! What a fantastic reference guide for the community. Thank you for making this available.
  3. ARKM's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2010
    From
    Terrebonne, OR U.S.A.
    Messages
    1,223
    Jan 15, 2017, 2:05 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #28

    Very cool. Thanks.
  4. russellsch's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jul 2015
    From
    South Carolina
    Messages
    1,305
    Jan 15, 2017, 2:07 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #29

    Well, there went my morning
    Best book I've read in while. I love it!
  5. knibbsey's Avatar
    Member Since
    Nov 2015
    Messages
    23
    Jan 15, 2017, 3:20 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #30

    Fantastic...thanks so much for this. Just starting to read it now. Thankyou!

    Just noticed on page 7 that Roger Christian is identified as Production Designer on ANH. He was a set decorator and prop maker. John Barry was the Production Designer.




    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
  6. Chris RPF Premium Member teecrooz's Avatar
    Member Since
    Mar 2002
    Messages
    1,897
    Jan 15, 2017, 3:42 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #31

    Some nice work Seth, it was fun to read through!
  7. Member Since
    Jan 2012
    From
    Columbus Ohio
    Messages
    152
    Jan 15, 2017, 4:09 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #32

    One nitpick on the Luke ROTJ V3 . the Graflex clamp has 3 holes drilled or punched. Other visible holes are tears in the foil tape. The run thread for Spirit of OB1's V3 post 54 has details. Awesome Book.
    http://www.therpf.com/showthread.php?t=267595&page=3
    Don Mac
  8. SethS's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2016
    From
    Los Angeles
    Messages
    1,862
    Jan 15, 2017, 4:30 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #33

    Wow guys-- thanks for the praise. Again-- I just collected the lore and made it look pretty. All the real work has been done here on the RPF over many years. All of this info is already here on the site-- I just wanted it to be easier to find.

    mkstewartesq said: View Post
    This is really great! I haven't built a saber in at least 10 years, and I yet am still finding it really fun just for pleasure reading.
    That being said – is there an error in the second paragraph of the page with you first start to discuss the Skywalker hero lightsaber in ESB? I could be misreading it but it seems to contradict itself. Sorry I can't seem to cut and paste the exact language from the PDF – but the second sentence says that the ESB Production seemed to have acquired their flashes from a "supply that was made later than the original." But then the very next sentence states that "these versions pre-date the ones used in ANH". So it seems to say that the flashes used in ESB were made later then those used in ANH – but it also seems to go on to say that the ones used in ESB were made first. Am I just misunderstanding what is written here?
    I'll try and make that more clear-- what I meant was the brand of Graflex itself (The Folmer) predates the Patent Number brand.

    ESB used Graflexes made in the 30s and early 40s versus ANH which used one from the late 40s to 50s. Not that the props themselves pre-dated ANH, but that the source parts used in ESB were older than the ones in ANH.

    THAT said, we never see the endcap clearly in ANH, and depending on when the odd promo pic of Luke in black on page 48 was taken, it's possible ANh used a folmer after all given the shape of the glass eye.

    Between all the stunt versions, back up parts, and TFA, one would assume they likely have some patented Graflexes in the mix somewhere since they seem to be more common.


    knibbsey said: View Post
    Fantastic...thanks so much for this. Just starting to read it now. Thankyou!
    Just noticed on page 7 that Roger Christian is identified as Production Designer on ANH. He was a set decorator and prop maker. John Barry was the Production Designer.
    Ah! Great-- thank you!

    Sixth Element said: View Post
    One nitpick on the Luke ROTJ V3 . the Graflex clamp has 3 holes drilled or punched. Other visible holes are tears in the foil tape. The run thread for Spirit of OB1's V3 post 54 has details. Awesome Book.
    http://www.therpf.com/showthread.php?t=267595&page=3
    Don Mac
    Thanks for the link. This is what @PoopaPapaPalps was pointing out as well. I think I get it-- I just didn't describe it very well. In an effort ot be precise I was more confusing. I may just have to be more general "IT HAS HOLES!"
    Last edited by SethS; Jan 15, 2017 at 5:53 PM.
  9. Coldhands RPF Premium Member Sundowner's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2010
    From
    Midwest
    Messages
    7,077
    Jan 15, 2017, 4:32 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #34

    This is awesome Seth! Thank you for sharing!!!
  10. SethS's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2016
    From
    Los Angeles
    Messages
    1,862
    Jan 15, 2017, 4:53 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #35

    mkstewartesq said: View Post
    This is really great! I haven't built a saber in at least 10 years, and I yet am still finding it really fun just for pleasure reading.

    That being said – is there an error in the second paragraph of the page with you first start to discuss the Skywalker hero lightsaber in ESB? I could be misreading it but it seems to contradict itself. Sorry I can't seem to cut and paste the exact language from the PDF – but the second sentence says that the ESB Production seemed to have acquired their flashes from a "supply that was made later than the original." But then the very next sentence states that "these versions pre-date the ones used in ANH". So it seems to say that the flashes used in ESB were made later then those used in ANH – but it also seems to go on to say that the ones used in ESB were made first. Am I just misunderstanding what is written here?


    In any event – great job and thanks again!

    M
    haha-- never mind. sorry-- I just wrote LATER instead of EARLIER because I am an idiot.
  11. Member Since
    Jul 2014
    Messages
    243
    Jan 15, 2017, 5:07 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #36

    Wow, this is wonderful - spent the morning reading it. Thank you so much
  12. cboath's Avatar
    Member Since
    Dec 2001
    Messages
    5,041
    Jan 15, 2017, 5:09 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #37

    -I'd take the real world parts bit and integrate it with the description/details of each of the sabers.
    -You use terms we're all familiar with (beer tab (lot of people today don't know what a real beer tab is , gear, shroud, etc) but in terms of an actual book, a photo or drawing point out those pieces would be a good addition as well.
    -Don't be afraid to use lots of text. You're trying to give the history, usage, parts, etc. It can be a lot of info. Use it. You don't have to infringe on the photos. Look at the companion book to Mysteries of Myth or whatever the prop tour was called in the 90's. Great photos, but pages of text explaining things as well.
    -I noticed, too, it include 4-6 with the TFA graflex and a shot of what probably would have been luke's TFA as well. Why leave out the prequels? Stick with what was used on screen. They have a bit less history as they're most machined, but still. Lots of cool stuff could be done with those as well.

    I put comments first (which you asked for) because they tend to not be read as much if they're second I think you've done a very good job but I think this is something you could take all the way to publication!
  13. SethS's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2016
    From
    Los Angeles
    Messages
    1,862
    Jan 15, 2017, 5:21 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #38

    cboath said: View Post
    -I'd take the real world parts bit and integrate it with the description/details of each of the sabers.
    I was trying to stick to a saber a page, and it got really hard to do that when I tried it this way. I think that my intent is to just show the differences of the props, and get people started on the basic info. There is a version of this that could be a detailed build manual, but I feel like that info is out there in several places.

    cboath said: View Post
    -You use terms we're all familiar with (beer tab (lot of people today don't know what a real beer tab is , gear, shroud, etc) but in terms of an actual book, a photo or drawing point out those pieces would be a good addition as well.

    Don't be afraid to use lots of text. You're trying to give the history, usage, parts, etc. It can be a lot of info. Use it. You don't have to infringe on the photos. Look at the companion book to Mysteries of Myth or whatever the prop tour was called in the 90's. Great photos, but pages of text explaining things as well.
    I went back and forth on this. I don't disagree with you, but I ultimately decided that I didn't need to compete with Lucasfilm about covering props for a general audience. Like I said, this is directly for people who would find themselves here or at wannawanga looking to convert a Graflex or get in on a project run or something similar. Educating general audiences adds an entirely new layer that I'm not sure I want to really take on.

    cboath said: View Post
    -I noticed, too, it include 4-6 with the TFA graflex and a shot of what probably would have been luke's TFA as well. Why leave out the prequels? Stick with what was used on screen. They have a bit less history as they're most machined, but still. Lots of cool stuff could be done with those as well.
    Like I said in the intro, the PT sabers don't really have a complicated story or lineage that needs explaining. Nor are they reworkings of real world parts. It's a pretty simple story-- they were designed by the production artists and build by the prop department from scratch. If I was documenting every saber out there, I'd totally include them-- but that's also a different type of project.

    I included the TFA sabers only because they had roots to the OT props-- just like I mentioned the ROTS sabers inspired by the OT versions.

    cboath said: View Post
    I put comments first (which you asked for) because they tend to not be read as much if they're second I think you've done a very good job but I think this is something you could take all the way to publication!
    Thank you! I'm totally not blowing your comments off, I just think you picture something a lot bigger than I want to tackle!
    Last edited by SethS; Jan 15, 2017 at 5:35 PM.
  14. RPF Premium Member newmagrathea's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2014
    From
    Kansas City MO
    Messages
    1,199
    Jan 15, 2017, 5:42 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #39

    Excellent work! I've been browsing through this and it looks to be very thorough.
  15. Mystery Chunk RPF Premium Member PoopaPapaPalps's Avatar
    Member Since
    Oct 2010
    From
    IA, USA
    Messages
    2,885
    Jan 15, 2017, 6:03 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #40

    SethS said: View Post
    It goes like this...
    From what I gather, that is correct, yes.

    SethS said: View Post
    I said " foil tape surrounds the clamp; a round hole is present below the oval slot and to the left of the square hole below it through the tape and clamp; a second hole, just in the tape, lies on the other side...
    Roy's post answered this.

    What do you make of the pic on the V3/share stunt page in the bottom right. I included it cause it was rigged with blade for dueling, and the color looks Yuma-ish... but I'm just now seeing a very black booster section.
    That is one of ANH shared stunts. If we're going on the idea that the V2 never had its clamp removed, then it would most likely be the V3/Shared Stunt. I believe that pic is from an old ESB BTS video so it lines up with the idea that both the V2 and Shared Stunt looked alike up until a certain point in the making of RotJ. However, that shouldn't be taken as "the V3 turned into what it looks like now", though it may have lead to it. I'm under the impression that what it looks like now is a result of touch ups and redressing after production had finished on RotJ for archival or promotional reasons.
  16. SethS's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2016
    From
    Los Angeles
    Messages
    1,862
    Jan 15, 2017, 6:06 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #41

    PoopaPapaPalps said: View Post
    That is one of ANH shared stunts. If we're going on the idea that the V2 never had its clamp removed, then it would most likely be the V3/Shared Stunt. I believe that pic is from an old ESB BTS video so it lines up with the idea that both the V2 and Shared Stunt looked alike up until a certain point in the making of RotJ. However, that shouldn't be taken as "the V3 turned into what it looks like now", though it may have lead to it. I'm under the impression that what it looks like now is a result of touch ups and redressing after production had finished on RotJ for archival or promotional reasons.
    Ohhhhhh okay. It makes so much more sense when you say that BTS image is from ESB and not ROTJ.

    thank you!
  17. Member Since
    Jan 2016
    Messages
    12
    Jan 15, 2017, 6:26 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #42

    This is truly worth being printed to a book to put alongside a saber collection! Thank you!
  18. RPF Premium Member kevin926's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2016
    Messages
    1,266
    Jan 15, 2017, 6:42 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #43

    Well done, nice job. Thanks for sharing this.
  19. Sym-Cha's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jun 2008
    From
    Groningen, Netherlands
    Messages
    5,798
    Jan 15, 2017, 6:48 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #44

    Hi Seth,

    Thanks for including me in this project . . . personally I would foremost give credit to George Lucas of Lucasfilm Ltd. . . . for without whom this galaxy far, far away and from a long time ago would not exist nor would the infamous lightsabers wielded by the jedi knights as written down in the Journal of the Whills ... also Chris Trevas and Chris Reiff from Parts of Star Wars website should be mentioned by name even before others and myself ... they laid down the ground work or building blocks from which others could rise to the occassion and share their discoveries with all of us.

    That said . . . I'm looking forward to many more revisions which will include even more information on lightsabers yet to be discovered and revealed. I for one know one other person residing in Rancho Obi-Wan, Petaluma California by the name of Steve Sansweet who would love a digital copy or perhaps even a real printed version to be reviewed and added to his famous collection

    Cha´m
  20. RPF Premium Member DylanRose's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2016
    From
    Seattle
    Messages
    120
    Jan 15, 2017, 7:19 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #45

    Wow. This is so great.

    Only question now is when are we doing a run for the physical version for our nightstands?? ha
  21. andrew25rs's Avatar
    Member Since
    Feb 2013
    From
    Rancho Cucamonga CA
    Messages
    416
    Jan 15, 2017, 7:49 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #46

    Looks great! I'll definitely buy this if it gets to that point. If you decide not to sell it then at least give us some way to offer a donation to you. Your work on the poster then this is excellent.
    Is there any plan to do something for the prequel lightsabers?


    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
  22. Member Since
    Jan 2016
    From
    Knoxville, TN
    Messages
    72
    Jan 15, 2017, 7:56 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #47

    I'm gonna echo everyone here and just say you have done us all an incredible service. Thank you so much!

    If you were to ever print this I'd buy it in a heartbeat. Thank you so much for putting together such an amazing and beautiful resource!


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  23. SethS's Avatar
    Member Since
    Jan 2016
    From
    Los Angeles
    Messages
    1,862
    Jan 15, 2017, 8:23 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #48

    Sym-Cha said: View Post
    Hi Seth,
    personally I would foremost give credit to George Lucas of Lucasfilm Ltd. . . . for without whom this galaxy far, far away and from a long time ago would not exist nor would the infamous lightsabers wielded by the jedi knights as written down in the Journal of the Whills ... also Chris Trevas and Chris Reiff from Parts of Star Wars website should be mentioned by name even before others and myself ... they laid down the ground work or building blocks from which others could rise to the occassion and share their discoveries with all of us.
    Lucas-- OH I GUESS.. maybe I'm still a little bitter about the PT... but you're right of course.

    I didn't know the names of the partsofsw guys, so without doubt I will now include them!

    Sym-Cha said: View Post
    That said . . . I'm looking forward to many more revisions which will include even more information on lightsabers yet to be discovered and revealed. I for one know one other person residing in Rancho Obi-Wan, Petaluma California by the name of Steve Sansweet who would love a digital copy or perhaps even a real printed version to be reviewed and added to his famous collection
    Cha´m
    That would be awesome! Steve was the first guy to really get in there and dig, paving the way for Don Biess and JW Rinzler to add their contributions.


    andrew25rs said: View Post
    Is there any plan to do something for the prequel lightsabers?
    Like I said-- probably not. There's no mystery about their construction. This book is for people looking to build an OT saber from sourcing parts. Since the PT sabers were designed and fabricated from scratch, you either buy a replica, a resin cast, or 3D print one.

    They are also fairly well documented. In fact, one of the things that got this happening was my son's copy of the Official Lightsaber Guide from Lucasfilm. Most of the OT props covered are wrong. The Skywalker saber, Obi-Wan's saber, and Vader's saber are all represented by their ROTS versions. Luke's Jedi saber is technically right-- but of course it's the "hero" not the V2 or Yuma.... damn it, that book really pisses me off! ;P

    I just don't love the PT sabers. The designs held by the stars (Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, Mace, Yoda, Anakin) are cool-- but I really dislike the ROTS versions of the OT sabers, and beyond them, pretty much every other saber you see is the same basic design. The entire Jedi council (that isn't a main character) has a minor variation on the same design, and I always thought that was a major cop out.

    DylanRose said: View Post
    Wow. This is so great.

    Only question now is when are we doing a run for the physical version for our nightstands?? ha
    Thank you!

    A few people are asking about a print version. I'm inclined to say no-- mostly for three reasons:

    1. The legality. Even though I never have plans to sell, a print version might indicate that I do. Even if it were to cover print costs, the fact that I can't source the legal owners of most of the images, that means I'd be opening myself up to trouble. I also don't know how Lucasfilm would feel about such a thing. I intentionally designed it at an odd size with no print bleed and let the page count fall in a way that it's not an easy print and run.

    2. Ownership. The best way around the legal problems would be to have the material copyrighted, but I'm not comfortable with that given that all the work was done by other people. I just organized this all. The second I put it out as a book, I'm suddenly the voice/face/expert and I don't think that's fair to the countless people who contributed to this-- especially since none of this contributions were specifically FOR this. I'm just giving back to the community, I don't now, or ever, want to, or expect to, get any money for this.

    3. It's organic. This isn't meant to be a permanent thing. I plan to update it regularly. I made this last week. In the last TWO DAYS we've made new discoveries about the V2. A print run would require minimums and I don't want to be stuck with a box full of outdated information! At some point, we'll see more of the V2. We'll find the t-track. Roy will stop being soooo lazy and draw blueprints for other sabers. If I keep it electronic, it's always easy to update and keep current.

    Now, all that said... I did build it at a high enough resolution that it could be printed. If somebody wanted to take the PDF to a copy shop, pay to have some color prints made and trimmed out, they are more than welcome to.

    Once we get through this beta I'll get the first official version done, and Roy has been kind enough to host it at wannawanag where anyone can download it and do what they like-- just like the lightsaber tree.

    The only thing I don't want is for somebody to print it and sell it. That would be a dick move.
  24. RPF Premium Member
    Member Since
    Dec 2015
    Messages
    1,230
    Jan 15, 2017, 9:55 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #49

    Amazing work Seth! This is awesome! Thank you for sharing
  25. RPF Premium Member
    Member Since
    Sep 2011
    Messages
    987
    Jan 15, 2017, 10:36 PM - Re: The Ultimate Guide to Lightsabers eBook #50

    Obi-Wan hero has an aged brass neck grenade windvane, which can appear very close to bronze. They may have used bronze paint on the V2 neck to approximate the aged brass.

    For the ROTJ hero, though, check the screen cap of the ISYHCANL hero and look at the control box bars, which match the neck in color, also the on set pic of Mark resting his chin on the Yuma: brass all the way.

    Can't speak to what paint was used on the resin stunts of the hero-- most agree that it's something between brass and copper.

    But only brass was seen on screen. Even the hero construction scene, the neck is dimly lit at firest and it looks like it could be copper. Then the light hits it, and you're like, "ah...yep, brass."

    SethS said: View Post
    It goes like this-- right?

    Obi-Wan's hero had a bronze neck, the stunts were mostly matte black to cut down on light bouncing during the duel. To approximate, the necks were hit with bronze, likely on top of the black (as we're noticing on the V2 right now!

    The V2 was scraped down to look how it looks.

    The V3's neck was painted copper, which the Yuma and close-up "hero" emulated.

    Right?

Similar Threads

  1. The Amazing Spiderman 2 (TASM 2) Ultimate Suit Guide
    cardboarddude, Marvel Costumes and Props
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: Nov 18, 2014, 2:08 AM
  2. Replies: 29
    Last Post: Mar 14, 2008, 9:03 PM
  3. Stargate SG-1 Ultimate Visual Guide Book
    phase pistol, Replica Props
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: Sep 11, 2006, 10:45 PM
  4. Looking for: Vader - the Ultimate Guide magazine/book
    Simba, Star Wars Costumes and Props
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: Aug 14, 2006, 1:45 PM