Well thats a good question. lol. This is my second cast. The first one I did came out completely matte. I do not know if I am answering your question correctly but I will give you my best attempt. The mold is made of UltraCal. I intentionally put in a texture when I sculpted the mask. So there is a texture in the mold. Before I pour the Vytaflex 40, I put a couple of coats of Sonite Wax and then a couple of coats of Ease Release.
The only difference I had from the first time I did the cast was instead of applying the wax with a stipple brush I used a sponge to avoid the hairs that sometimes fall off the brush. My best guess is that because I used a sponge some areas may have more wax than others. But I'm not sure. Does that make sense to you? I hope I gave you enough information about my process.