Awesome! Thanks for the info. I was leaning towards some sort of Acrylic paint, but had not found the leather/vinyl specific kind.
Since we are sort of on the topic of the Arm quiver. I just finished my version of the arm quiver. Its pretty straightforward stuff, but in case anyone needs more help with that piece I'll post some info on how I did mine.
Here's my first quick attempt at the arm quiver. I used the one that came with my Leather costume, and turned it into more of a Season 2 look. Anyways, i ran out of time to work on it before the Sci Fi Expo. It served its purpose.
View attachment 291231
I started with a fore arm guard similar to this one.
View attachment 291233
I then cut pieces of cardboard, black vinyl (included with the original arm quiver) and some polyester scrap fabric I picked up at Johann's. Mostly used hot glue to combine the different layers. My arm quiver is approx 7 " long.
View attachment 291234
Then added the nylon straps and piece of Velcro.
View attachment 291236
The rubber arrow locking pieces I picked up somewhat randomly. I bought a cheap practice bow and it came with one 5 arrow lock. Then I purchased a cheap quiver and used the arrow lock from that. This is the one I used,
Amazon.com: Bohning Sentry 3 Arrow Quiver, Black: Sports & Outdoors . Bohning also sells just the rubber arrow lock piece. Its not screen accurate but its close and cheap.
View attachment 291235
1/4 inch wooden rods work well, and fit the arrow locks. Painted the wooden arrows black/metallic silver. Then painted my Arrow vanes a lighter more yellowish green. Attached 2.25 inch Vanes/fletching to the wooden rods. The arrow vanes I used were these
Amazon.com: Bohning 2.25-Inch Shield Cut X-Vanes (36-Pack), Neon Green: Sports & Outdoors
View attachment 291237
Then I used hot glue to attach the rubber locks to the nylon straps on the quiver. And added a few fabricated "arrow-heads".
View attachment 291240
I'm pleased with the results, its not screen accurate but its definitely closer than I was before, and a vast improvement from the original. Note: I purchase whatever i can through amazon simply because of the free shipping i get with amazon prime. :thumbsup
I don't know if this information was really needed, but everyone on this forum is so great and helpful. I wanted to contribute what little I could. Hopefully more to come as I continue to work on upgrading my Arrow costume.