Wow, that sounds... pointless. "Hey, I can quote this scene word-for-word! Oh look, I completed the level!" Yawn. Furthermore, why would I want to watch someone else doing that? It sounds like the karaoke of video games, or a third-rate community theatre production of a Broadway show - painfully awful, and a constant reminder that you'd rather be watching the original.
Well, it sounds boring because you're looking at it from the wrong perspective.
Agreed - when used in the book, it was one of the cooler little touches, and was meant to demonstrate that only a person who had obsessively immersed himself or herself in all things that Halliday adored (like WarGames/Holy Grail) could move to the next level. And in the book, the descriptions of these flicksyncs are pretty abbreviated, so there's no line-by-line run-through of the movie that would bore the reader. Out of context, sure, it sounds like a drudge - but, in the book, it fits perfectly.
That being said, I've heard nothing to indicate that these are used at all in the RP1 film, and I always suspected that they wouldn't be. One reason being that cited by Angelus Lupus - it wouldn't translate well to the movie format, and would run the risk of being tedious unless exceedingly brief. Second - and in line with the various other updates we've seen that no longer tie the film strictly to "80s" references, I doubt many in the audience today would get much of a buzz off of watching a character reenact "WarGrames" - let's face it, other than maybe the line "Shall we play a game?", that movie hasn't exactly stayed top-of-mind in the collective consciousness of the movie-going public. "Holy Grail", while still an amazing film, also isn't much of a blip on the radar of the general public today like it was in the 80s. And I doubt they'd preserve the flicksyncs but replace them with more modern films. Third , of course, is whatever effort might be needed to clear yet another set of rights to use a third-party property.
But who knows? - I'll be going in relatively unspoiled as to what from the book is included and what isn't, as there hasn't been a lot of info on that point so far. (Though I am still bummed that they reveal the "real people behind the avatars" from the get-go, unlike in the book; holding the reveals of Art3mis and Aech until the end was one of the best things about the book, and would have played beautifully on-screen.)
M