I'll keep this as brief as I can for now... expect more posts later, as I think of them...
The recent GREEN LANTERN movie has resparked my interest in the comics. I've been a lifelong GL fan, and it kind of amazes me that there have been relatively few ring replicas that are fairly true to the comic designs. I have several of them--the Blackest Night promo, the 1990 promo, etc., but none of them have really scratched that itch to have a high-quality, comic-accurate, wearable GL ring.
I love my modded TRU Movie ring, but that's, well, the MOVIE ring, and my first love is the comic. There's an elegance to the comic rings. I get why they went with the weathered crystal/metal look for the movie, but I prefer the solid green metal style of the comics.
I first hit upon the idea of anodized aluminum as the best option for that YEARS ago... I don't remember exactly how many, but the thought was inspired by seeing Mag-Lite brand flashlights and other trinkets (keyrings, etc) with an anodized aluminum finish in a green color. I was not yet a member of the RPF in 2002 when Megatron did his very first run of anodized aluminum Green Lantern Power Rings, so I missed out on that run... but more on that topic later!
Of course, there have been countless artistic interpretations over the years, but three basic designs have been used over the years (aside from Alan Scott's and some other variants for the very non-human GLs):
* The original/Hal Jordan style.
There's even an interpretation or 2 of that ring that you've missed, but more on that later....
Gil Kane's original version of Hal Jordan's ring was essentially a simple ring band (akin to a wedding ring band--no detailing, and the same shape/width all the way 'round), with a disc on top emblazoned with the GL symbol. The symbol, of course, went through many, many evolutions over the years, from the original, more complex design, to the classic version used for licensing, to the recent modification of that design (with the slanted sides on the top and bottom).
Also, don't forget that Gil Kane also drew Sinestro's original yellow power ring as looking the same as the GL ring, just made of "yellow metal"...
That picture also shows another major variation on the way Gil Kane drew the ring in the early days, with thick bars at top and bottom, and a thin circle in the middle. Back around 2000 or so, this inspired GL Super Fan and Costumer Leman Yuen to make some resin power ring replicas inspired by that design and sell them through the EmeraldDawn.Com website. This resulted in the first replica of the yellow power ring that I ever saw available for sale:
As you can see, his skill at casting translucent resin doesn't match up to newer ring makers such as customizedhero/BatJeepster, Zenix, and the like. But for the time, it was pretty good, and the only thing available. He supposedly only made 30 of the yellow rings, of which I have 4.
It was Gil Kane's design for the yellow ring that also inspired me to commission the centerpiece of my power ring collection, the ULTIMATE wearable power ring prop...
Sinestro's original yellow power ring, made out of 14K gold, back before the price of gold went through the roof!
For fans of Sinestro and his Corps, this is the ultimate way to have a wearable power ring prop. But it's simply too costly for most nowadays. I paid $350 for mine when I got it, but it would now cost $700 OR MORE. Most fans these days would have to settle for a gold-PLATED ring instead. :unsure
* The "Version 2" Corps style.
Mike Grell's 1970s redesign eliminated the disc-on-band look, and went with a 3-D version of the GL symbol (minus the circle surrounding the symbol) stuck on top of a band. This version also went through many variations, until it stabilized under the hands of artists like Joe Staton and Dave Gibbons.
The only real variation of this design is that some versions feature a center gem (depicted as either flat and flush with the GL symbol, or a dome-shaped gem protruding from the face of the symbol, as in the last image of the three seen below).
This is my all-time favorite version of the ring, probably due to it being what Hal was wearing in 1984 when I first picked up the book. In fact, that ring on the left looks very familiar...
^Cover to
Green Lantern (Volume 2) # 181... the first issue of
GL I ever purchased! And how could you NOT pick it up with that cover? That was something that NEVER happened in a superhero comic!!!
thumbsup
* The "chunk" style.
This is a distinct variant of the V2--on this one, the GL symbol blends into the band, with the grooves going all the way around the band (or not, in some cases). The GL movie ring follows this style, despite its being the least-seen of the three main types.
There's a new variation of this, the "Honor Guard" ring that's been seen in the comics recently:
Basically, the "chunk" ring is now RIBBED... for her pleasure? :lol
And of course DC Direct quickly cranked out a crappy replica of it... looks just like the standard chrome-plated chunk ring, but with the added ridges on the side. And it costs like 2-3 times more than the standard chunk ring, probably because it comes in a fancy box! :lol
My "perfect" GL rings would go something like this:
Hal: Anodized metallic green metal ring. Two-part construction (GL symbol-disc atop simple band). No two-tone color scheme for inset portions of symbol.
While it's not the "disc on band" construction you like, Megatron's most recent runs HAVE been the signet style rings, both "old" Hal and "new" Hal/Corps designs, in anodized aluminum!
Here's the "old" Hal ring that RPFer Djinn owns:
It has a rougher texture and a slightly less metallic look. The one I bought from him (which I really need to photograph) is from his most recent run, and has the finish I was waiting for, a smoother, glossier, much more metallic look, similar to what you see on the Mag-Lites. BEAUTIFUL ring, the best wearable rings ever! When he gets around to doing another run, ORDER ONE! You won't regret it!
thumbsup
He also had a run where the anodizer did a much lighter color, more of a "lime" green that reminds people of the coloring seen in some of the earlier comics. Here's the entire batch in that color, in which you can see both the "old" Hal and "new" Hal styles:
Mixed in towards the center is the other green finish, like Djinn owns. More of an emerald green. Some have described the texture as making the ring look more extraterrestrial in nature, so some like it.
V2: Anodized metallic green metal ring. Two-part construction (3-D GL symbol atop a simple band). One version without a gem, and the other with a lighter, lime-green-ish "dome" gem.
Which is exactly what Megatron produced in his very first run of anodized rings back in 2002!
After searching for years, I was FINALLY able to add one to my collection just last month, when Megatron found out he still had an old, imperfect prototype in my size!
So, here's my V2 anodized aluminum ring...
Those pictures were taken by Megatron. It looks darker in person than in those pictures, I figure his flash is really bright. Here's a quick pic I snapped with my cell phone camera, using its flash:
I'd thought about adding a light green, cabochon style gem to the center, but decided against it given how rare these rings are. But if Megatron ever does another run in this style, I'm going to suggest adding the center stone. :cool
Thoughts? What are your favorite GL ring styles? What artists have drawn your favorite rings? Do you like some of the really far-out styles of the alien GL rings?
My favorite will always be the Version 2, as drawn by Dave Gibbons and the other artists of the mid-'80s. But seeing some of the earlier drawings of it from the late '70s, I definitely see where some of the inspiration for the movie's ring comes from. :cool
Most importantly, when and how will the definitive comic-style rings be made, and by whom? It's really amazing that such relatively simple designs have never quite been done justice. I think a two-piece construction on the Hal and V2 style rings would make the task easier. Although, as noted, Megatron's signet-style rings look really sweet.
Megatron is the only one making anodized aluminum rings, and he doesn't make them very often. On the rare occasion when he does a run, you HAVE to get in on the run, or you can literally be waiting YEARS for another run! Right now, he's on orders from his Uncle Sam, so it's going to be awhile before he can do any runs of ANYTHING, not just GL rings. :unsure
Yeah, there are a lot of variations. The GL symbol itself went through many, many evoultions. Even though the symbol we know was established fairly early on (although it was often depicted with a green center circle instead of white), later artists like Neal Adams continued to tinker with it.
Yep. Pretty much every artist has done their own interpretation of the ring. And for the record, I HATE the latest "official" ring shape, which DC Direct has used in the last couple years for all the current PVC promo rings, their official light-up ring set, AND their most recent high-end metal ring prop set, done as part of the Justice League Trophy Room line. It's the most retarded shape I've EVER seen for a signet ring! And the thicker they make the face, the more ridiculous it looks! So the light-up rings, with added thickness to accomodate the LED and battery, look even WORSE. :thumbsdown
As noted, I prefer the "disc" look to the true signet ring, since that's what Kane drew.
Interesting side note... several years ago, there was a guy on eBay selling metal rings with the design you prefer. He didn't stick around long. I have a feeling he was just recasting DC Direct's sculpt. They may have sent him a C&D order.
I saved the pics to my hard drive, but these haven't been available for years... still, might work for showing Megatron what you want.
Someone really should create a visual flowchart of all the ring variants, so that some kind of concensus could be reached on the best versions.
I have no skills in that regard, plus, this is all just ARTISTIC LICENSE on the part of the artists. Officially, there's the "old" signet style ring, the Version 2 ring, the "chunk" ring, and the "new" signet style ring. Different artists just draw them different ways.
Which reminds me, somewhere in all that, you complained about "squashed" symbols. Again, artistic license from the hand guiding the pencil. The DC Direct "Gil Kane" style ring with the "squashed" symbol seems as though it was partly inspired by the artwork of Mark D. Bright...
this is from
Green Lantern: Emerald Dawn...
And I am shocked that Jack T. Chance has not chimed in here!
I hadn't even seen the thread until you PMed me about it! :lol
A few years after GREEN LANTERN/GREEN ARROW was cancelled, the series was relaunched. Mike Grell redesigned the power rings, with the in-universe reason being that these were new-and-improved models.
And the biggest improvement, which explains much of the seeming inconsistency afterwards, was that the ring's form could be ALTERED by its wearer! In one issue, Hal disguised his ring as a pair of SUNGLASSES to go undercover! :lol
So, from that point forward, the ring doesn't HAVE to look like the ring you see as my avatar... it can be a signet style ring,
more of a wristband than a ring, it can be an
F-SHARP BELL, it can be a pair of sunglasses, whatever suits the preferences and/or needs of the wearer. :cool
Check it out! You can see the Vulcan GL in that image! \\//,
Bottom left looks the closest to Megatron's sculpt. :cool
And there's a few major variations of the rings that you didn't list yet...
- The Super Friends version, white disc & band with green logo on face.
- Kyle Rayner's ring from Superman the Animated Series:
- John Stewart's ring from Justice League:
- The ring as seen in Green Lantern: First Flight and Green Lantern: Emerald Knights:
- The power ring from the upcoming Green Lantern the Animated Series:
And... I'm spent!