There are many ways to get a metal look on cast parts. What you really need to comprehend is the final finish and purpose. Cold casting is very wasteful and labor intensive while also only working on specific parts or else details are lost or parts brittle. The base material is also a major factor as is the base material color vs the metal finish desired. A black base thats shiny will have a better color on most metal finishes while other metals would require a grey tone. Its all trial and error. But first as stated, you need to comprehend the final result then make a materials list. The base powders sold by the material suppliers have a mesh of 325/425 or so. This is only good for adding to the casting material (ie wasteful and more work) vs a 4000 mesh which is more like super fine dust and flows like water. Its all too much to explain but ive been using metal in molds for many years now and learned by sole trial and error in both materials and powders.
What I will tell you is working with metal powders, wear a respirator and eye protection. NOT a painters dust mask but an actual filtered respirator. That metal once inhaled, is in your lungs to stay unless you end up with a respiratory issue and your lucky enough to have your lungs vacuumed. Then you get to see metal come back out and the look of horror on a doctors face when they think your a Terminator but thats another story.
I dont understand why people are so dedicated and stuck on Smooth On products. Use what works, not whats cheapest. Cheap means nothing when parts fail for whatever reason. Im certain Smooth On has the right product for other uses but I use MPK90:
Casting Resins, cast, resin, hobby* clear resin, hobby, professional, high quality resins
Its the right material for the job, hands down. Its not Onyx or whatever the others are selling but is MPK's own product.
These are NOT cold cast parts but are right from the mold as is, as seen. The base material is MPK90 but the method took me years to perfect. Again this goes back to the right materials for the job. It wasnt till the advent of the MPK90 that the method worked.
Everything here including the grips is raw cast strait from the mold. The gun being cast in parts as well, strait from the mold in color.
These have a black wash, decal letters and a clear coating:
and again showing what the surface looks like after some paint color and a wash being added. The shine holds up,