Axlotl
Master Member
Leonardo DiCaprio.
And I feel terrible about saying it because he's been in many top-notch films from the greatest Hollywood directors and it's apparent that he has an immense commitment to his craft and works harder than 99% of Hollywood... but he's never crossed into the pantheon or truly transcendent talents in my mind. He's never been terrible but he's never blown me away, either. He's starred in some really good films but don't think I've ever seen a film and said, "oh boy, this one's got DiCaprio in it ..." I won't say he doesn't deserve his success because he clearly works really hard. Is he a great actor I'm not appreciating? Or is he just a good actor who made all the right moves in Hollywood to have friends in the right places to get where he's at? (e.g. I recall he was able to get Spielberg to do Catch Me If You Can only because he did the director a big a favor by hanging out with Spielberg's daughter who was a fangirl over Titanic.)
He's one of those actors who (IMO) just shows up and reads lines.
He reads them well, no doubt, but I'm always aware I'm watching Leo DiCaprio.
He doesn't disappear into roles like (IMO) better actors do.
He used to be very good...
I thought he was great in "What's Eating Gilbert Grape" and "The Basketball Diaries".
Those were the last films he truly acted in, though (IMO).