IFA, if it makes any difference, I owned a set of screen used wallets for a while, and the STSCARTS replicas are dead on, including the coloring/weathering of the badges. If you specified something different and you didn't receive it, I guess that's a different matter. But yeah the STSCARTS stuff is where it's at.
The wallets pictured above came with the badges. They're not totally correct, but they read well. It's really hard to tell from the opening credits what the size of the things are, but for me these do the trick. I got the wallets on etsy from a chinese seller. The one bummer is there's an FBI stamp on the back side. But then, who knows, maybe that was in the screen used ones too.