Lately for me it's been Breaking Benjamin, the lead singer is a good friend of mine, and the song is called Diary of Jane. So do you have a song that you can listen to over and over again because it's so good?
Funny, I've actually been listening to a lot of Breaking Benjamin as of late. He's got a great voice and I love the drum tracks on most of their songs. Breath and Diary of Jane are two of my favorites, but as of right now, I'm listening to Give Me a Sign a lot.
According to iTunes (which I think was reset about a year and a half ago)... it's Metallica's Broken Beat & Scarred.
The first non-Metallica songs are All Along the Watchtower by Bear McCreary, then London Dungeon by The Misfits, followed by Crush Crush Crush by Paramore (which I know I haven't listened fully to in almost 2 years).