Got to agree there. Your skin-tone paint is great, but the eyelashes, eyebrows and watery eyes detract from it.
You should try trimming the eyelashes, then squash/crumple them a bit so that individual hairs overlap and clump instead of splaying out and not touching each other. The perfectly straight, splayed look tends to only be seen on females who use mascara and eyelash brushes.
I know you're going for more "life" by wetting the eyes more, but the liquid you use tends to pool along the lower eyelid making Arnie look like he's crying or has allergies. Honestly, I'd just stick with unaltered glass eyes.
And the eyebrows - I know I've pointed it out before, and you're doing for a more budget approach, but they really don't work well on Arnie. He has really bushy eyebrows, and the ones you use are too thhin/sparse. The gel(?) that the hairs are attached to also has a thickness that casts a slight shadow and makes them obviously stuck on. Gluing on clumps of hairs is the way to go. If you use small clumps instead of single hairs, it'll go much fast and with Arnie's thick brows will look right.
Please don't take this as a put down. You're painting work has come on leaps and bounds, but it's always the eyes, eyelashes and eyebrows that (for me) never quite look right. Hopefully what I've said was constructive enough, and if you have any questions, I'd be happy to help. :thumbsup