It's not going well at all. I was on Ven Zallow server with over 2k people 3k on weekends when Patch 3.0 hit it went to 3k peak on weekdays. Right after, they announced that ranked pvp would not be in the next patch basically the entire player base left. 1 month after the patch went live I logged in on a Saturday at 5pm and I was the only person on the entire server.
The problem with the game is that it plays like a single player game with a storyline. Once you get to the end of the story-line there is nothing to do but pvp and a few small story based instances. There is no roleplay elements and they do not encourage any sort of community, there is no free roaming space travel or battles -spaceship combat is on rails, and impossible to beat lvl 60 missions- not only that there item system is not unique at all, everyone looks the same. In a genre like Star Wars that isn't a good thing.
I see gaggles of misinformation like this...a lot. The server merge was needed. I won't say the "entire player base" left, but I will say the population took a hit. A big hit. That said, everyone KNEW F2P was coming. It's the new business model for MMOs.
A lot of what you have posted are strictly "opinions". Not a shred of it is true. Granted, you may have been one of a very small group of people on your instance at your particular time, but that does not mean you were the sole player on the ENTIRE server. Nope, not buying what you are selling here. Soooorry.
I have found MORE RP on my new server, good RP at that, than 4 years of WoW. Space missions are"difficult", not impossible. I've beaten every space mission there is. All it takes is knowing how to use ALL of the tools on your ship, and it had best be maxed out before you try those missions. Hard, but VERY doable.
PvP on this game is actually FUN. If you use your class abilities well, you can have a FAIR fight. I know, shocking. They almost give you gear to get you started in PvP now. That gear will also get you through some hard flashpoints until you get better gear. The item system is VERY unique now. You can take modifications from one piece of gear and add them to another to make YOUR look. Hell, I took my mods for my Juggernaut and added them to some Tusken gear for PvE and Imperial Trooper gear for PvP. I haven't seen a game like that since SWG...and TOR does it better.
Sorry man, a lot of what you have posted is outdated bull. If you don't like the game, fine, don't play it. I am enjoying it. I took a break, came back and have grown quite fond of it.
I'll be the first to tell you that there are flaws. Take for instance being able to buy a chair with Hutt Cartel coins...yet you can't sit in any chair in the game that is not on your ship. Chat bubbles are STILL not in the game. It is a system resource HOG as well. If you get past those things, you will find enjoyment. I have.
Oh, time for some troof. There is NO level cap on F2P. You are limited in the things you will be able to do for "FREE", but shouldn't that be the case?
Here is the complete list.
Anyone who thought TOR would be a WoW killer was deluded. I never saw it happening as WoW has years of bug bashing under its belt. That said, it is a fun game.
Hell, the Penny Arcade crew predicted this F2P right at launch.