I'm not a big ST fan. Never was. Liked TOS and a couple of movies. All 24th century stuff had it's great episodes but overall I remember more episodes that I wouldn't really rate as "good".Spoken like a true Star Trek fan. Lol. It's so good I can't wait for season 2. Bad writing prior to any 2009 Star Trek huh? This is funny.
It's all a matter of taste. I like ST VI more than any other ST movie. Even heard people complaining about this one. And I never liked anything with Q involved.