The photo would be good along with Teddy's notebook (not a diary). He is a US Marshall, the notebook is used for writing down clues and info. Also their IDs would be great.
As far as the movie goes, and this is my opinion, Marty Scorsese owes me $9.00 and 2 and a half hours of my life back. I saw it the second day because I heard there was a great twist to the movie and I didn't want some one to ruin it for me. No twist. Disappionting story. Great acting, costumes and sets, and excleent filming. But without a good story to hold it all together? I felt it was very predictable.
Another prop might be pateint files.
Best,
DBCooper