The screen-used badge is 4.25" x 3.5" (closed). The SalesOne badge is 4" x" 3.15". The eFX one seems to be the same size as the screen-used badge. Since the SalesOne badge is smaller than the screen-used and eFX one, I don't know if your replacement ID card would fit correctly in the SalesOne badge. I can't give you any in-hand opinions since I don't have the SalesOne badge.