When I see people paying what can only be described as stupid or irresponsible sums for things like this, it absolutley confounds me, especially when the identical, real world item can be had for reasonable amounts of money. Why pay $140,000 for a graflex saber when you can have one for $200.00? Okay, so Mark Hamill didn't hold it on screen. For all you know, the same holds true of the $140,000 one. Could you even tell the difference? Same for this gun. I found an original online in less than five minutes, exact same gun with the original military holster for $1300.00
I can appreciate your perspective; some of the prices realized for original props are incredible, and not something some of us "mere mortals" would be in a position to contemplate (myself included!).
Having said that, an authentic and iconic artifact from a classic film is something special. It is part of our popular culture. It is a piece of art. Many times, such things are one of a kind.
More, with a property like Raiders of the Lost Ark, or Star Wars, an authentic original prop that can be owned "in the clear" is a rare thing.
Lucasfilm archives everything. Many of the few authentic original props that are "out there" may not officially be "out there".
Because studios and productions often don't own the firearms that are used in the films (for a variety of reasons), this is one piece that can be owned, legally, openly, and notoriously.
There is great value in that.
Is it "worth" $180,000? Well, to one person it is. Going by the bidding, having watched it, two people think it's worth $170,000. I lost track of when the third person went out, but to three, it's worth a bit less than that.
Me? I'd rather have a wide variety of pieces that add up to $180,000 (if I had that much to spend on props - I don't).
But yes, you can buy the same type of piece for little money. But having the one that was used by Harrison Ford, in the production of the film, and seen on screen...
That's an important piece from an important film.
And we're all here for love of films. I think we all just have different ways of appreciating them and paying tribute to those icons we see on screen.
If anything, the event of the sale of this piece makes for an interesting conversation.
Jason