Quest for the Ultimate Ranger Sword (LOTR)

Lunaman

Sr Member
This began as a post in the 'grail' thread, but my word gushing was growing out of hand as I typed and I decided to splinter my discussion of this precious item off into its own area. :lol I'm new to the RPF, but I've been a collector for a long time, with my interest primarily in swords.

When I first began collecting awesome things, my 'pie-in-the-sky' single desire was to own a real, functional ranger sword like the one Strider wields in the Lord of the Rings films. That was my Excalibur, the artifact that filled me with a childhood sense of wonder and magic. I picked up the officially licensed United Cutlery wallhanger version early on, but it felt dead in my hands and wasn't built to be a useable weapon. It's a good-looking replica, but it wasn't for me.

To clarify what more I desired, here's a quote by my favorite swordsmith, Peter Johnsson, about the fundamental power and fascination associated with a sword.
A sword is a symbol of many things. The complexity of its associations adds to its symbolic power.

When you handle a well made sword it is difficult not to be affected by this. The sword represents chivalrous ideals, but it is also the weapon with which the warriors slew the innocents.

It is a significant symbol for the continual strife for mastery, for good and for bad. It is a sign of both triumph and defeat. It is a tool whose influence can make man a hero or a mindless destroyer.

It takes knowledge to make a sword and it takes experience to know how to wield it, but it has often served powers that are motivated only by prejudice and ignorance. For modern man it might represent a longing back to ages long past which are believed to have been easier to understand and grasp. Still, if a sword is not first of all made to be a fully functional weapon, it is a pitifully foolish thing that cannot carry any symbolical power.

A sword must not fail in its practical use. A badly made sword is a very disappointing thing, since sloppy, thoughtless and careless craftsmanship belies the very source of its intrinsic power. The purpose of the shape and dimensions of a sword is to ensure its wielder control of the thin line of its edge, across which it ceases to exist. The need to be alert and conscious about how the overall shape sets conditions for the details, and how the details lead to results in the performance of the completed sword is an inspiring necessity in its making.
This is the type of power and respect that the ranger sword represented for me, so a wallhanger simply wouldn't do.


It took me over a decade, but I got my real ranger sword. Mind you, I didn't end up getting a screen accurate one (though I know they exist). I got something better. At least in my eyes.
In the years since I've started collecting I've learned more and more about swords and developed tastes that went beyond simply replicating the exact sword seen in the film. I wanted a blade profile with slightly more taper and historical influence. I wanted the grip to be deep red instead of green. I wanted a shorter cross guard and a more elaborate hilt shape, but with fewer brass details. I wanted a ranger sword that truly belonged to me, though still one Aragorn would approve of. A sword that was true to its historical predecessors in function, true to the film inspiration in appearance, and true to my own preferences in detail, "a well proportioned, responsive and reliable weapon."

To custom commission something that specific from a trusted smith would cost many thousands of dollars and be worth every penny, but I lucked out tremendously when one of my favorite cutlers teamed up with the most well-respected production sword company in the business to produce something that lined up perfectly with my desires for a much more economical price. I ordered the very first one that was available.
DSCF2134.jpg


This is a semi custom Borderwatch by Christian Fletcher and Albion Armorers and it's magnificent. Dream achieved. :eek

The blade is 6150 high carbon steel, made by Albion Swords of Wisconsin. Their lead designer, the aforementioned Peter Johnsson, took hands-on documentation of hundreds of authentic medieval swords and combined the features of certain examples into an idealization of the Oakeshott type XVIa longsword form, which was in use around the time of the 100 years war. These measurements were transferred to a CNC computer-controlled milling machine that carved out the blade blank to match the dimensions, mass distribution, and distal taper of authentic medieval swords as directed by Peter's research. The blade was then heat-treated using forges and a molten liquid salt bath, quenched, and given a spring temper and a hard edge from the rearrangement of the molecule structure within the steel. The blade was then refinished and sharpened by hand. Normally, the blade would be then be hilted up to become an Albion Next Generation Crecy, but this finished blade was sent to Christian Fletcher to become my Ithilien Ranger sword. A video showing the process of creating an Albion single-handed sword can be seen HERE.

Christian Fletcher then crafted the crossguard, pommel, and grip ring from mild steel and fitted them to the blade.
30progresspic.jpg


The Grip core was carved from poplar and shaped to an elegant taper.
30progress2.jpg

The hilt assembly was peened (riveted together using the end of the tang) and risers and leather wraps were applied to the grip sections, bound by cord while they dried, and then hand-dyed to a deep red.
30final1.jpg

The hilt was then given a light bluing, and it was sent to me. It's probably my finest possession.
30Final3.jpg

DSCF1065.jpg

DSCF1075.jpg

DSCF1084.jpg

DSCF1086.jpg




I could not afford one of Christian's custom scabbards at the time I ordered.


I have made do in the meantime with a United Cutlery scabbard that I got for $50 because the sword and byknife were missing. I modified a Generation 2 seax for the byknife and added a belt made by Valiant Armory. Shockingly, the scabbard fits quite well, so I'm no longer in any particular hurry to upgrade the scabbard set up.
DSCF2214.jpg

DSCF2211.jpg

DSCF2131.jpg


Thanks for reading,
--Luna


>>P.S.
A little bonus regarding all the talk about functionality and mass distribution. I don't have any video of my sword moving around, but here's some footage of my friend Mike doing some target cutting with his Albion Crecy, which is built on the same blade as my ranger sword.
VIDEO: CUTTING WITH THE ALBION CRECY
Enjoy. Swords are just the best. :)
 
Last edited:
i love that first sword. ive been looking for the same thing, i love gondors armor and weaponry. this fits the style very closely
 
i love that first sword. ive been looking for the same thing, i love gondors armor and weaponry. this fits the style very closely
Thanks! Just to be clear, though, all of these pictures are of the same sword. :) The middle pictures show in-progress stages as it was being made.
 
Beautiful beautiful sword, seriously drool-worthy. Thanks for sharing! Will you be making/getting a costume to go with it? It'd be cool to see a custom ranger to go with the custom sword.
 
Beautiful beautiful sword, seriously drool-worthy. Thanks for sharing! Will you be making/getting a costume to go with it? It'd be cool to see a custom ranger to go with the custom sword.
Thanks for the kind words! Happy to share.:)

I don't currently have any plans for a costume, but I wouldn't put it past me to do it eventually. Something like this would be very nice to accompany the blade. But considering how many years it took me to put together something as simple as a Dread Pirate Roberts outfit, I'm sure I'd end up obsessing and tinkering and wouldn't be satisfied until I had something as detailed and specific as the version westies 14 put together, and the size of that project terrifies me. :eek:confused:lol
 
Thanks for the kind words! Happy to share.:)

I don't currently have any plans for a costume, but I wouldn't put it past me to do it eventually. Something like this would be very nice to accompany the blade. But considering how many years it took me to put together something as simple as a Dread Pirate Roberts outfit, I'm sure I'd end up obsessing and tinkering and wouldn't be satisfied until I had something as detailed and specific as the version westies 14 put together, and the size of that project terrifies me. :eek:confused:lol

You said the sword took a decade right? What's another decade? :lol By that time all the Hobbit movies will be done, too! :behave
 
You said the sword took a decade right? What's another decade? :lol By that time all the Hobbit movies will be done, too! :behave
Hahahaha, exactly! Might as well have it ready for the inevitable mega movie marathon that'll go down. :)
 
Such a lovely piece! Have I mentioned that you are a lucky guy ;)

Now it gets me wondering what a more historically realistic Narsil would look like :)
 
Such a lovely piece! Have I mentioned that you are a lucky guy ;)
Haha, thank you!
Beautiful, a good looking sword is definitely on my list as well
Thank you! I've had dozens on my list. :lol

Now it gets me wondering what a more historically realistic Narsil would look like :)
Christian made this version a while ago. I'd love to see one built on this blade, an Angus Trim XIIa.1.

My friend Brendan Olszowy recently collaborated with Jeffery Robinson to make this version of Anduril with a bronze hilt, which I think is pretty rad, but the weight and blade profile are more in line with the movie prop than with historic examples.

I myself fill my Narsil fix with this beauty pictured below, with a red grip to match my ranger sword. It's a Christian Fletcher Austrian Greatsword, built on an Angus Trim XIIa.4 blade. I think they only made 4 of these. I love mine.
DSCF1338.jpg

DSCF1339.jpg
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I always imagined the Narsil from the films as a form of Type XIIa.

In fact, now that I think about it, there was a member here by the name of David Stokes who had photo's of a custom project that was made for him by Vladimir Cervenka. It was based on a historical longsword design with added embellishments to give it the character of Anduril.

These are the only surviving pics on the net of it, he used to have more detailed photos but they are gone now it seems.

anduril_201.jpg


download.php


Another style based on the same model was done also it seems:

vc2_116.jpg


vc3_192.jpg


vc4_121.jpg


The sword it was based on can be seen here:

detail10.jpg


obrazek3m.jpg
 
Yeah, I always imagined the Narsil from the films as a form of Type XIIa.

In fact, now that I think about it, there was a member here by the name of David Stokes who had photo's of a custom project that was made for him by Vladimir Cervenka. It was based on a historical longsword design with added embellishments to give it the character of Anduril.

These are the only surviving pics on the net of it, he used to have more detailed photos but they are gone now it seems.

Another style based on the same model was done also it seems:



The sword it was based on can be seen here:

You can't hotlink images from MyArmoury, but I'm familiar with Vlad Cervenka's work and I'm sure his versions were beautiful. Went looking through David Stoke's history and it seems we have similar tastes in blades. :lol I'll do more investigating later this evening.
 
I just recently discovered Fletcher's work. Maeglas and Borderwatch inspired a few Middle Earth OCs of mine. I'm incredibly happy to find out that his swords are fully functional weapons. Hopefully I'll come upon the thousand dollars I'll need to pick up a Maeglas of my own soon. Congrats on getting your grail!
 
I just recently discovered Fletcher's work. Maeglas and Borderwatch inspired a few Middle Earth OCs of mine. I'm incredibly happy to find out that his swords are fully functional weapons. Hopefully I'll come upon the thousand dollars I'll need to pick up a Maeglas of my own soon. Congrats on getting your grail!
Thanks so much! Yea, Christian doesn't mess around with wallhangers.:lol I know a couple people who have picked up the Maeglas sword and are quite fond of it. It's a really beautiful piece, even though the minimal distal taper on the blade isn't quite my cup of tea. It's still light enough to be very agile.

I also have one more Fletcher longsword that feels right at home in Middle Earth. One of the few Venetian Bast**d Swords that he made. Christian's a wonderful craftsman.
DSCF0917.jpg



In fact, now that I think about it, there was a member here by the name of David Stokes who had photo's of a custom project that was made for him by Vladimir Cervenka. It was based on a historical longsword design with added embellishments to give it the character of Anduril.
I did some digging and it turns out I was already familiar with and a fan of many of the projects David has worked on in the sword world! His projects with swordmaker John Lundemo are some of my favorites.
His FIRST and SECOND projects with the wonderful Peter Lyon (the swordmaker who MADE the hero props for the Lord of the Rings films) are amazing and reflect the same sort of spirit and dedication that went into my search for the ultimate Lord of the Rings weapon. I'd like to buy him a beer. :eek

Yeah, I always imagined the Narsil from the films as a form of Type XIIa.
Yea, I like the spirit of that sword fits well with the older 13th century broad cutters, kingly pieces of steel. Which is why I'm so chuffed to bits with my Austrian; it just screams power and authority when you hold it and it's a pretty brutal cutter. Here's some test cutting one of the Angus Trim vendors did with the prototype blade.
Austrian Warsword prototype Test Cutting.wmv - YouTube
 
Last edited:
Back
Top