I can't see you doing better than the folks who made them, agreed. I have a sterling Hansen One Ring as my wedding band, and I love it. Heavy little sucker. I imagine wearing the gold one is like hanging a six pack off your finger.
I bought the sterling silver ring and had them gold plate it for me. It looks great in my collection.
I also have a sterling silver One Ring that I had gold plated, plus the sterling silver chain. They're on display in my theater, I'll take pics tonight. I'm very pleased with it, however, it's for display only - I ordered the ring in the size that it is when Frodo wears it on the chain. Waaaaaay to large a size for me to wear.