I have the choice of either the EFX or RS prop masters Red 5 Luke helmets. Wanted to know which is the more screen accurate between the two? Thanks.
EFX RED 5 LUKE OR RS PROP MASTERS?
- Thread starter Scruffylooking
- Start date
gschram92
Member
EFX is a bit big and way more expensive (generally) than RS. I paid a TON to get the ESB signature edition EFX and I loved it. The quality was okay but it was a licensed product and it had Mark’s actual signature.
Eventually I started not to care as much since I wasn’t “there” when it was signed. I ordered a custom RS prop ESB variant of the helmet by sending them the screen caps from the movie I wanted them to emulate. Waaaaay more actuate. Size was Better. And a fraction of the cost. Go with RS.
Eventually I started not to care as much since I wasn’t “there” when it was signed. I ordered a custom RS prop ESB variant of the helmet by sending them the screen caps from the movie I wanted them to emulate. Waaaaay more actuate. Size was Better. And a fraction of the cost. Go with RS.
Perfect. I’ve actually already got the celebration Mark signed plaque, so an ESB variant will go nicely with it. thanks for the answer.
I have both the Efx and RS Props X-Wing helmets and the RS Props one is much more screen accurate than the eFX one in shape, size and materials. I also cross referenced the RS Props helmet with an SDS X-wing helmet I bought a looong time ago and they are very similar in size and shape. I just have to say though that I don't buy SDS products anymore and the x-wing helmet I have of theirs, like I said, I purchased many years ago, but it does seem to be quite screen accurate as well. The SDS I have has no paint work and also the visor on it is incorrect. The Efx helmets, while not exactly screen accurate are very well made and are nice collectibles.
But, if you are going to purchase a new X-wing helmet I would definitely go with the RS Props helmets for accuracy, quality and reliability in delivering product in a reasonable amount of time. The paint work and weathering are also very well done on the RS Props helmets. I now have two of their Signature Edition X-Wing helmets and plan on buying more in the future.
But, if you are going to purchase a new X-wing helmet I would definitely go with the RS Props helmets for accuracy, quality and reliability in delivering product in a reasonable amount of time. The paint work and weathering are also very well done on the RS Props helmets. I now have two of their Signature Edition X-Wing helmets and plan on buying more in the future.
ggriffaw
Sr Member
I don't know if the RS Props Red 5 helmet will have a similar wait as the Porkins helmet I just ordered, but it sounds like it will be a few months before they can make it. They have several production runs for other items in process or on the schedule. I asked about ordering a Snowtrooper bust. They said that would probably be a few months as well.
I'm happy with my RS X-Wing helmets. The only thing I didn't like was the position that the microphone is attached. Its too close to the face so when I'm wearing the helmet, the mic is literally pushing against my lips.
If you only plan on displaying it only, it's not a problem at all but if you plan on doing any trooping or just trying on the helmet once in a while, the mic makes it unwearable.
I plan on getting Red 5 eventually and when I do, I'm going to ask Andrea (their customer service rep) if they could extend the length of the mic or at least reposition it in a more ergonomic way. They're very accommodating at RS so I don't doubt they would do it if requested.
If you only plan on displaying it only, it's not a problem at all but if you plan on doing any trooping or just trying on the helmet once in a while, the mic makes it unwearable.
I plan on getting Red 5 eventually and when I do, I'm going to ask Andrea (their customer service rep) if they could extend the length of the mic or at least reposition it in a more ergonomic way. They're very accommodating at RS so I don't doubt they would do it if requested.
Last edited:
OldTraveller
New Member
Definitely go with RS Props. I've a few of their x-wing helmets now - some signature series and some commissioned - and they quality of work, detail and customer service is all of a very high standard, plus they are screen accurate in size and shape.
As others have said, the Efx is slighly large and expensive. SDS is closer in size although has inaccuracies in terms of some dimensions on top of the visor (I also have a couple purchased many, many years ago) and it probably sits somewhere in between the two in terms of screen accurate size but I would absolutely not buy from them.
Pic of some of my RS x-wing helmets - not the best picure from my phone and the angle distorts somewhat but the helmets are all works of art.
As others have said, the Efx is slighly large and expensive. SDS is closer in size although has inaccuracies in terms of some dimensions on top of the visor (I also have a couple purchased many, many years ago) and it probably sits somewhere in between the two in terms of screen accurate size but I would absolutely not buy from them.
Pic of some of my RS x-wing helmets - not the best picure from my phone and the angle distorts somewhat but the helmets are all works of art.
Attachments
ggriffaw
Sr Member
I have several of the RS Props X Wing pilot helmets. They are very nice quality.
However, for people who want it to feel like an actual helmet, they may not be a good choice. Some don't like ABS. They aren't for those people.
It depends if you want a prop replica or something that feels like a real helmet.
However, for people who want it to feel like an actual helmet, they may not be a good choice. Some don't like ABS. They aren't for those people.
It depends if you want a prop replica or something that feels like a real helmet.
nope totally get that
Hunter120844
New Member
These are very cool. Sorry for the dumb question, but does RS do custom helmets if you ask them to that aren’t part of what is listed on their website?
russellsch
Master Member
Why yes, I do.
The last one’s not centered. So Luke’s helmet, which is bigger, looks way bigger.
PHArchivist
Master Member
Is that the ESB version (presume so)...?
Thanks for the comparisons
russellsch
Master Member
Yes sir it is. Good eye
. One of the “warehouse finds”. It’s an AP, came with Mark Hamill signature, & I got it for retail price!! The later “finds“ were marked up in price, otherwise I would’ve picked up the TIE Fighter.You’re so very welcome. Happy I could help.
Similar threads
- Sale
