Amazing. Right away, I see a difference in the pommel grooves unless I’m mistaken
EFX 2024 Obi-Wan TPM Legend Edition saber
- Thread starter janglesworthy
- Start date
It got delivered too late in the day to use my good camera, I had already lost my good light and didn’t feel like setting up the photo box. Here are some pictures from my phone.
eFX on top, AS/Dewy on bottom:
eFX on the left, AS/Dewy on the right:
AS/Dewy on top, eFX on the bottom:
Overall, there is nothing too groundbreaking here. It is a very nice replica, but I disagree with some of the design choices. I’m obviously very biased, and I want to spend some more time looking it over before I go into details or talk about accuracy.
eFX on top, AS/Dewy on bottom:
eFX on the left, AS/Dewy on the right:
AS/Dewy on top, eFX on the bottom:
Overall, there is nothing too groundbreaking here. It is a very nice replica, but I disagree with some of the design choices. I’m obviously very biased, and I want to spend some more time looking it over before I go into details or talk about accuracy.
Its very good for anyone who prefers an officially licensed replica.
Accuracy aside, there’s just something so magic about the AS/Dewy that makes me love it. All the research, discoveries, and discussions - documented here on an RPF thread
Accuracy aside, there’s just something so magic about the AS/Dewy that makes me love it. All the research, discoveries, and discussions - documented here on an RPF thread
They look nearly identical to me. I guess both Dewy and Efx did good on reproductions.
Exactly!!
Looks, um... smaller lol but really nice!!
I'll be finding a way to use my extra Starkiller blanking cap from the salt shaker run
Definitely some major differences, in favor of the D/AS but eFx did a marvelous job and it's beautiful and am super excited to add this to the TPM group
As you should be. They missed some obvious designs details, (in my opnion) however looks like a beautiful hilt. They did get that one step that we missed on the main body shroud of the D/AS. Beautiful hilt but yours and Dan's attention to the details is not comparable
I think that’s just the angle of that one photo. They’re actually very close in size. Nearly identical.
Yes, just saw your other pics
AnubisGuard
Master Member
I'm pleasantly shocked at how close they are. Really good endorsement of both versions, down to Dewy/AS nailing the size.
Patlegrand
Active Member
Very nice piece
I wish I had more money when dewy/AS was up is someone wants to sell one kit, tell me!
I wish I had more money when dewy/AS was up
is someone wants to sell one kit, tell me!
sakanade
Well-Known Member
Very nice replica overall, however it is a bummer they didn't get some stuff right. To be honest I wasn't really expecting it to be as good as the AS/Dewy Ver.
What could be?
Yeah, but kudos to them for not trying to copy other works. For the most part, sans a few things, they got a lot right on this piece but as Dewy said, nothing groundbreaking as the D/AS was and is^ They should have visited the RPF
Some of these details I didn’t really know or understand until Dewy/AS made them for us to see. Take the uneven emitter column groove. Or the weird shoulder cuts. Stuff like that. EFX made some version of these in theirs! It’s absolutely bananas to me, and I want to offer my incredulity.
That being said, we’re so spoiled, the AS/Dewy replica is even better than this.
That being said, we’re so spoiled, the AS/Dewy replica is even better than this.
Similar threads
