I don't think it was Roger Christian... was it Norman Reynolds?
The more time passes, the more I really wish we had some sort of verbal history, or story about how Obi-Wan's saber came together.
Even with his spotty memory when it comes to detail, we've heard Roger's various versions of finding the Graflex after Lucas had rejected various other proto-saber designs. I don't think it's a jump to say that once they had the Graflex they looked to other camera flashes as well... and if you were looking for an evil version of the Graflex, how could you see the MPP, all black and chrome, and not instantly think it was perfect for Vader?
But did Obi-Wan's come before or after these two? How were the completely disparate parts chosen?
I assume we've all seen (I put it in the guide) the image of the various proto-sabers that Lucas rejected. Clearly all of them evolved from MacQuarrie's concept art... or rather, one or two of them did, and the rest evolved from there.
One of those concepts includes the Hales grenade, so we know that part was in the running early on. That makes me wonder if maybe the Obi-Wan saber was rejected as a the Luke/Anakin saber. The emitter has a similar look to the concept art.
But that said, it also has a Graflex clamp, which would have been a part chosen after the Graflex was approved. Was it added to a concept saber? Did they just slap stuff together randomly with a similar exterior diameter? I know this is the most likely scenario, but I would still love to know.
AnubisGuard and I were theorizing the other night and he brought up another interesting question... All the concept art shows a pretty universal lightsaber design. When did Lucas decided that each lightsaber should be unique? Did he look to how each character with a blaster got a unique gun (outside of troops) and apply the same logic?
These things keep me up at night.
The more time passes, the more I really wish we had some sort of verbal history, or story about how Obi-Wan's saber came together.
Even with his spotty memory when it comes to detail, we've heard Roger's various versions of finding the Graflex after Lucas had rejected various other proto-saber designs. I don't think it's a jump to say that once they had the Graflex they looked to other camera flashes as well... and if you were looking for an evil version of the Graflex, how could you see the MPP, all black and chrome, and not instantly think it was perfect for Vader?
But did Obi-Wan's come before or after these two? How were the completely disparate parts chosen?
I assume we've all seen (I put it in the guide) the image of the various proto-sabers that Lucas rejected. Clearly all of them evolved from MacQuarrie's concept art... or rather, one or two of them did, and the rest evolved from there.
One of those concepts includes the Hales grenade, so we know that part was in the running early on. That makes me wonder if maybe the Obi-Wan saber was rejected as a the Luke/Anakin saber. The emitter has a similar look to the concept art.
But that said, it also has a Graflex clamp, which would have been a part chosen after the Graflex was approved. Was it added to a concept saber? Did they just slap stuff together randomly with a similar exterior diameter? I know this is the most likely scenario, but I would still love to know.
AnubisGuard and I were theorizing the other night and he brought up another interesting question... All the concept art shows a pretty universal lightsaber design. When did Lucas decided that each lightsaber should be unique? Did he look to how each character with a blaster got a unique gun (outside of troops) and apply the same logic?
These things keep me up at night.