this is great. i would love to help out trying to find images for this prop. i can also do some amazing work on photoshop and try to recreate a high res photo. im working on a high res photo of the matchbox too. if ud like to see what i have so far let me know. i procrastinate alot so with some encouragement i can move faster.
I'll take you up that. Here's the image that I found on ebay and a link to the high res image.
For a real rabbit hole, see if you can find what the image is from the tail or snake shape in the lower right corner.
This was close which led me to think it was Hanuman.
And if that's not challenging enough, what's this image to the left of the Krishna image? Squinting at the pixels, it looks like a a dark skinned figure wearing a red crown who is seated, possibly in the lotus position or on a dais, with a tail or snake protruding on the left side.
The search may be slightly easier that expected as it looks like the Krishna image is repeated.
The image right of Krishna is not the same in this photo - note the yellow flower at the base of the cow's leg.
In this photo, no yellow flower. Assuming this image appears twice, then the other image likely does as well.