ok.
this is to check to see if im kicking off the new year being a good boy, or if im gonna be on santas naughty list this year.
please note, this is COMPLETELY HYPOTHETICAL. i lack the molding/casting skills god gave a retarded monkey with tourettes.
4 scenarios. opinions wanted on all 4, and just be bluntly honest about feelings, etc. this is not only to check me and my morals, but to sort of be a moral compass for any newbies to the hobby. sort of a "good/bad prop/resin karma with bitchslap you FAST in this hobby" warning.
on to the fun.
1: i bought a thingy on ebay. this thingy is awesome. i love this thingy. the only problem with this thingy is it would be WAY cooler if it had lights and sound. therefore i want shiny new thingy with lights and sound.
do i
a: contact the seller, say "yo dude, im like totally dropping this in silicone and im making some spare copies for me, cause i wanna make it light up and make noise. never planning to sell em, just wanted to say thanks for an awesome replica", then proceed in dunking in RTV regaardless of "ok" email by seller, and then using said copies as beta tests till i get my awesome new shiny light up and noise making thingy, chunk the beta test castings, and tear the mold up.
b: not tell the seller, cause he might freak, but make a few copies for me, and then proceed to use said copies until i manage to get one working. keep the mold since i worked this out, and in case my new shiny light up thingie breaks or snaps, i can cast up a replacement for me.
c: pester the seller to make one with the shiny light up and noise making stuff, and if they say no, just feel bad and move on with my life, and not make or own the shiny light up and noise making version?
story 2. little easier, just a 2 option answer . i am digging around in my greeblie/prop whatsis box (as any collector/kitbasher has a box of misc stuff too neat to throw away, but too weird to really warrant using RIGHT NOW). i come across a mystery doohickey. its made of resin, but i have no idea where i got this thingie from. the idea i have for a project will involve 5 of these things and i have only 1. since this is for a personal display thingie that i dont plan to sell, i decide to just lob it into silicone, make a quick and dirty mold, and finish up my costume. take pics, hang out with chicks cause my costumes cool, then set the thing up on the shelf. 5 months later i decide to sell this to pay rent or buy food or just get rid of something thats dusty.
a: do i post pics up and say "here is my costume thingiemabob. it is awesome in its pure sheer awesomeness. bid often and leave me rolling in the dough." and proceed to make money off the costume i wont wear again. the detail pieces are tiny anyway, and who cares. its freakin little tiny doohickey that i didnt even remember owning. could have had it for years, or at least months.
b: post up an auction, but NOT include the piece that i had recast, since i have no idea of the origins, and just say "hey, i recast this from a thingie i found. no idea where i got it, but it wouldnt be honest to sell it with these things. ill give you the measurements to make your own though", and if the maker of said items comes upfront about it, pass the info on to the person or get his ok to give the parts to the guy with the costume.
and story 3. i have a prop. no idea where it came from, just spawned from the pike of "to do's" that anyone has in this hobby. could be 5 years old, could be a year old, no idea. big dusty box. its neat, but i know i want a set of em. i mean one is awesome, but 2 really makes the display.
a: recast the one i have (minimal shrinkage due to first gen casting), and make my display set. dont bother anyone with pics or trying to track down someone across 15 diff boards and at least 3 years. if you sell it, sell the set.
b: try a few boards, and hope for some luck and a decent price on the second one. if you dont get a bite or a nibble after a few months, plop it in the silicone and make a display. if you sell display, make sure to either include the spare at no cost or just chunk it in the trash bin
story 4. kids birthday party (like 6 or 7 years old), something completely non prop related. say a star wars theme. you have an old luke ESB resin saber from god knows where, never finished up and just sitting there. you think the kids are gonna go completely apepoopy over the lightsabers. only a few days till the party though.. hmm....
a: ok to recast resin kit into a kids playtoy without asking who made it and getting permission.
b: go to the store and buy toy lightsabers, not as cool, but since you dont know the maker and you are in a crunch, itll have to do.
my personal answers on these are as follows.
1: c
2: b
3: b
4: a... only because its virtually impossible for a kid to get one of these, know what it is, recast it, and start selling em on ebay. you can substitute harry potter wands and a lathe and measurements taken from an existing wand in the collection, and use those instead of the star wars theme. same diff. its purely there as a situational thing, not a "i have one on the workbench." thing. something somewhat hobby related but not really enough to care about. a kid, and a toy.
anyone wanna chime in on em, decide your own answers and post em, and the reasons behind em?
note, this is NOT a bash someone thread, or a pick a fight with someone thread. its a public way of saying what you think about recasting and what you would do in the given situations. i think my compass is set right, but im open to debate as well. plus, as i said, lots of new guys to the hobby, and ive yet to see a thread pop up that starts out with "recasting is bad" unless theres something involved with that person and thier prop being recast.
so..... any takers on the quiz?
chris
this is to check to see if im kicking off the new year being a good boy, or if im gonna be on santas naughty list this year.
please note, this is COMPLETELY HYPOTHETICAL. i lack the molding/casting skills god gave a retarded monkey with tourettes.
4 scenarios. opinions wanted on all 4, and just be bluntly honest about feelings, etc. this is not only to check me and my morals, but to sort of be a moral compass for any newbies to the hobby. sort of a "good/bad prop/resin karma with bitchslap you FAST in this hobby" warning.
on to the fun.
1: i bought a thingy on ebay. this thingy is awesome. i love this thingy. the only problem with this thingy is it would be WAY cooler if it had lights and sound. therefore i want shiny new thingy with lights and sound.
do i
a: contact the seller, say "yo dude, im like totally dropping this in silicone and im making some spare copies for me, cause i wanna make it light up and make noise. never planning to sell em, just wanted to say thanks for an awesome replica", then proceed in dunking in RTV regaardless of "ok" email by seller, and then using said copies as beta tests till i get my awesome new shiny light up and noise making thingy, chunk the beta test castings, and tear the mold up.
b: not tell the seller, cause he might freak, but make a few copies for me, and then proceed to use said copies until i manage to get one working. keep the mold since i worked this out, and in case my new shiny light up thingie breaks or snaps, i can cast up a replacement for me.
c: pester the seller to make one with the shiny light up and noise making stuff, and if they say no, just feel bad and move on with my life, and not make or own the shiny light up and noise making version?
story 2. little easier, just a 2 option answer . i am digging around in my greeblie/prop whatsis box (as any collector/kitbasher has a box of misc stuff too neat to throw away, but too weird to really warrant using RIGHT NOW). i come across a mystery doohickey. its made of resin, but i have no idea where i got this thingie from. the idea i have for a project will involve 5 of these things and i have only 1. since this is for a personal display thingie that i dont plan to sell, i decide to just lob it into silicone, make a quick and dirty mold, and finish up my costume. take pics, hang out with chicks cause my costumes cool, then set the thing up on the shelf. 5 months later i decide to sell this to pay rent or buy food or just get rid of something thats dusty.
a: do i post pics up and say "here is my costume thingiemabob. it is awesome in its pure sheer awesomeness. bid often and leave me rolling in the dough." and proceed to make money off the costume i wont wear again. the detail pieces are tiny anyway, and who cares. its freakin little tiny doohickey that i didnt even remember owning. could have had it for years, or at least months.
b: post up an auction, but NOT include the piece that i had recast, since i have no idea of the origins, and just say "hey, i recast this from a thingie i found. no idea where i got it, but it wouldnt be honest to sell it with these things. ill give you the measurements to make your own though", and if the maker of said items comes upfront about it, pass the info on to the person or get his ok to give the parts to the guy with the costume.
and story 3. i have a prop. no idea where it came from, just spawned from the pike of "to do's" that anyone has in this hobby. could be 5 years old, could be a year old, no idea. big dusty box. its neat, but i know i want a set of em. i mean one is awesome, but 2 really makes the display.
a: recast the one i have (minimal shrinkage due to first gen casting), and make my display set. dont bother anyone with pics or trying to track down someone across 15 diff boards and at least 3 years. if you sell it, sell the set.
b: try a few boards, and hope for some luck and a decent price on the second one. if you dont get a bite or a nibble after a few months, plop it in the silicone and make a display. if you sell display, make sure to either include the spare at no cost or just chunk it in the trash bin
story 4. kids birthday party (like 6 or 7 years old), something completely non prop related. say a star wars theme. you have an old luke ESB resin saber from god knows where, never finished up and just sitting there. you think the kids are gonna go completely apepoopy over the lightsabers. only a few days till the party though.. hmm....
a: ok to recast resin kit into a kids playtoy without asking who made it and getting permission.
b: go to the store and buy toy lightsabers, not as cool, but since you dont know the maker and you are in a crunch, itll have to do.
my personal answers on these are as follows.
1: c
2: b
3: b
4: a... only because its virtually impossible for a kid to get one of these, know what it is, recast it, and start selling em on ebay. you can substitute harry potter wands and a lathe and measurements taken from an existing wand in the collection, and use those instead of the star wars theme. same diff. its purely there as a situational thing, not a "i have one on the workbench." thing. something somewhat hobby related but not really enough to care about. a kid, and a toy.
anyone wanna chime in on em, decide your own answers and post em, and the reasons behind em?
note, this is NOT a bash someone thread, or a pick a fight with someone thread. its a public way of saying what you think about recasting and what you would do in the given situations. i think my compass is set right, but im open to debate as well. plus, as i said, lots of new guys to the hobby, and ive yet to see a thread pop up that starts out with "recasting is bad" unless theres something involved with that person and thier prop being recast.
so..... any takers on the quiz?
chris