I'm a little worried about the consitancy of the speckle and the big black dots...
Just being honest Rob,
Brad
Comments/Response/Insight to this latest stage:
--First and foremost, once done, I wasn't as enthralled as I was with the upper dome. Don't know why, really. There's nothing going on I don't
dislike, and there are still opportunities to enhance what I have. Maybe since it was
second, I was just less impressed.
--This was
clearly too big of a chunk to tackle in one shot. I've learned that at most, I should limit my areas to about half of what you see. Yes, this amount of area makes consistency actually
harder to acheive.
--My initial impression is that the lower dome is lighter than the upper. Tough to tell - lighting is very different on the lower that the upper. You'd think that less direct lighting would make the lower look darker, but I'm not an expert in this arena. One thing is certain though; the lower dome received a lot more white than the upper, as the speckling - per the reference - is "busier" (more dense with more color variation) on the lower than on the upper.
--Plus, as Dave noted, the addition of the black marker and pencil lines (which there are TONS of) on the lower will no doubt effect the overall impression, and will almost certainly darken the appearance.
--Finally, regarding dots/speckling consistency, remember that one of my now standard and critical steps is to paint out the larger, more offending black dots. Y'all may not believe this, but its really not that difficullt or time consuming at all to go into a square and massage the speckling manually. I use a very light grey (almost white) to paint out the large black dots. The think about it for a sec - if this leaves a white blob that is too
big, then it is a slam dunk to just go back in with the black Rapidograph marker to add one or two much smaller black dots in the now-too-large white one. All this increcases the degree of granularity, resulting in a more fine texture.
--Beyond that (correcting dots that are too large), it is also surprisingly easy to go in with the Rapidograph or a pencil and just add a bunch more small black dots to each square. It takes probably 1 to 1.5 seconds per dot to add more, so in less than 30 seconds, I can add a moderatly decent number of black dots to any square, and darken to overall look (if necessary).