Anyone know of costume_bay quality?

Does anyone have experience working with costume_bay on ebay? He has several auctions and it looks like he does a ton of business.

Can anyone speak to the quality?

Thanks.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(rmschneider104 @ Dec 11 2006, 07:51 AM) [snapback]1375423[/snapback]</div>
Anyone?
[/b]

I cant speak for the quality as I havent seen anything of his in person, but...his ethics suck. He was using pics of my Wolverine costume a little while back to sell his suits. It couldnt have been a mistake because the pics were of 2 RPF'ers that they themselves had taken. This CostumeBay guy just took the pics and made them his own. Fortunately Ebay removed those auctions almost immediately. Funny thing after was he took real good close up pics of the Wolverine Sideshow action figure costume, and put those up as his costume pics...nice eh?

He's a scammer as far as I'm concerned. Sorry if that rubs a few people the wrong way.

David
 
I have 2 of his Han Solo costumes. The clothing is well made. I am keeping and using the shirts and vest for my Han costumes. The pants have huge inaccurate stripes and are larger than his sizing would lead one to believe. Though well manufactured, they're not always accurate. His leather holsters are decent though don't fit any of the blasters available.

His Jedi boots aren't bad but have large calves and lame spats and soles. His jedi belts are decent for the price but are missing some details. His Jedi pouches are garbage in my opinion. They used to be made of lame injected foam and now are made of wood so they can open and be "functional."

Basic rule of thumb with costume_bay:

His stuff is usually well manufactured but not always accurate. A good deal if you don't mind altering, modding, and adding to the pieces to get a good final product. Remember that the shipping costs are high. So don't get too excited by the low auction costs.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(DAVIDYR1 @ Dec 11 2006, 01:34 PM) [snapback]1375444[/snapback]</div>
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(rmschneider104 @ Dec 11 2006, 07:51 AM) [snapback]1375423[/snapback]
Anyone?
[/b]

I cant speak for the quality as I havent seen anything of his in person, but...his ethics suck. He was using pics of my Wolverine costume a little while back to sell his suits. It couldnt have been a mistake because the pics were of 2 RPF'ers that they themselves had taken. This CostumeBay guy just took the pics and made them his own. Fortunately Ebay removed those auctions almost immediately. Funny thing after was he took real good close up pics of the Wolverine Sideshow action figure costume, and put those up as his costume pics...nice eh?

He's a scammer as far as I'm concerned. Sorry if that rubs a few people the wrong way.

David
[/b][/quote]

David,
I think you are thinking of the ebay user HonestDragonChina, he is the one that uses close up pics of the action figure. Costume_bay has never, at least not that I know of, used figures in their auctions, only the pics of the somewhat decent suits. Check out the Honest Dragon fella. The suit sucks too lol.
 
I bought some BSG insignia pins from him, and they are accurate and good quality. He did take a bit longer than I would have liked to ship, but the pieces were coming from China.
 
I have 2 different full jedi costumes, the solo stuff and the BSG dress uniform/insignia. All told, excellent sewn quality but yes there are inaccuracies. For basic displays or for trooping/cons though they are a great starting or even ending place. Try to pool orders though due to the shipping and make offers on the ebay auctions. They will usually accept offers of between 25-50% of the asking price.
 
I have his black Anakin belt. I can't claim to know much about the quality, but it's worked for me the two or three times I've worn it, it is adjustible, and it looks nice - though I have heard that it's not extremely accurate. It certainly seems like it has a very high quality/cost ratio.

Also, on the Son of the Suns forum (dedicated to Anakin costumes) they've echoed the sentiment that his jedi gear is a good starting place, but will require some work to make it more accurate.
 
Costume Bay, also known as Pan-In-The-Box is located in Singapore so I had went to their old and new shop a few times to see see or get my item. They also have an online shop/website.

Personally, his Obi-Wan Costume is not bad tho' he's still not using the closest cloth for the Tunic, Tabbards and Obi which is available here cheaply. :love The pants is a pull-up pants when the original isn't. And if he did the same thing as he did with the Anakin Costume, the Tabbards and Obi are padded. I am planning to get this outfit from them on eBay as soon as I can win it for a lower price. :angel

For the Jedi Belt, it's Vinyl if I remember correctly (will check my Anakin one again). It does felt a little "plastic" IMHO. He used to have the details on the wider belt sew-on I think but now it's casted into the vinly to look like stitches which is not like the original (Obi's ROTS one is a plain brown belt). Think they just use the same mould for both Anakin's & Obi-Wan's Belts.

The pouches used to be sucky Styrofoam but now seems to be wooden (I haven't see it in person yet). The old ones also have the clip "clipped" to the pouches so it can fall off. Boots are also okay and meant for regular sized people's legs. The Anakin zip in the front if I remember correctly and have the front flap to cover it. For the Jedi Food Capsules/Pellets, it's obviously not accurate tho' it does close at the botton so you can put tiny things inside or loose the cap.

The Anakin Costume, seems to be made from Cotton Drill except for the Vinyl Tabbards.

For the Darth Maul one, the Outer Robe seems thin in their photos. Sometimes, I feel like they are using Chiffon. :eek Must really see it in person one day.

Padme Costume is okay; the details are there tho' isn't detail enough (just pieces sew together, no Flat Seams or something like the original). I dun like the pouches are they felt too chunky and the Blaster Holster really looked out of shape tho' can squeeze in the Rubies Padme Pistol inside it.

Their BSG Uniform is not accurate according to someone here who had his made by a good costume shop here (after intense discuss about the design, discussions about the materials and finding TheOne Material, import from outside Singapore) who also do the Star Trek Costumes for them (my friends). Think they probably used Cotton Drill too as many of their costumes are made from this fabric (FMA Roy Uniform, Street Fighter Evil Ryu Costume).

As for their Lucy Narnia Costume, it SUCK as they solely based it on the tiny action figure, thus showing a lack of research (even my favourite costume shop occasionally asked me for a lead to sites that studies the original SW, LOTR and other costumes). I was VERY disappointed when I saw it in person:
http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v640/idr...Pan-In-The-Box/

Long story short, their props are okay or good (NOT excellent huh) which most of their costumes suck in term of accuracy tho' for about 1/3-1/2, the average-normal-clothing-like quality is there. I will take the Obi-Wan or Anakin ones for random Jedi but it'll be an insult to myself if I use them for what they suppose to be. :p Dun even think they DID visit The Art of Star Wars Exhibition when it was here to check for more infos on the actual costumes.

As for response, when I won my Anakin Jedi Belt Set, I think they took a few days to reply to my e-mail (as my eBay registered e-mail address is not my current e-mail address) but they are nice enough to allow me to take my items from their shop and pay it in Singapore Dollars (I won them in USD). The seller also sounded nice in e-mails and on the phone, while the shop assistance are polite/nice. I guess they meant good in providing us the services for a place to get some of the costumes and props for our costume BUT in the end, cost comes first so not the bestest materials were used nor proper research done.

BTW, heard the stuffs were made in China. :unsure And the last time I went to their shop, the put up photos of costumers and cosplayers seen at a Cosplay Event here last year on their shop glass door. Deceiving IMHO as I'm sure they can't afford to sell Predator Costumes or Stormtropper Armors or many other Cosplay aka Anime/Manga related costumes.
 
I E-mailed him yesterday as to buying just part of a costume (i.e. the shirt from the ESB Solo instead of the whole costume). He replied (quickly) that they do not sell separate pieces.

Unfortunately, that was the deal-killer for me. Other than that, good-lookin' stuff for the price.
 
Honestly, you could get the whole costume for less than what a shirt made by any other reputable place would cost.

Keep the shirt and sell off the other pieces here or on eBay.
 
I bought some stuff from him too. His Indy MKVII bag is not accurate and smaller than the real deal. His Indy fedora is seriously pathetic... its a hard wool felt hat (I bought it before I knew better about Indy Fedoras; now I have an Akubra and an Adventurebilt.). I recently bought BSG rank pins from him and thank God they're good lookin'.
 
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(rmschneider104 @ Dec 10 2006, 06:40 PM) [snapback]1375134[/snapback]</div>
Does anyone have experience working with costume_bay on ebay? He has several auctions and it looks like he does a ton of business.

Can anyone speak to the quality?

Thanks.
[/b]

Do not get me wrong, but all his Jedi stuff is not accurate at all. Every people that I know who bought his stuff ended up selling it again on eBay. If you are looking for a cheap Halloween costume, he is your seller.
 
His BSG rank pin devices are lacking in any kind of accuracy and detail to anyone who knows what they really should look like, but the new sash decoration pins he's recently come out with seem dead-on the mark. Not quite sure why the difference, but there it is. Can't speak on the Star Wars stuff. Not really interested in it.
 
I agree on the well-constructed part, as well as the less than accurate part. I have his Indy gas mask bag and it's really nice, but not quite the right size. Still looks good for display or costuming though. I also have his ANH Solo belt/holster. It's well made and with only one minor modification I can fit my Denix Mauser replica in it fine. It's a great belt for the price, considering he'll take just about any offer through the "Make Best Offer" button on eBay.
 
Kinda old thread, but ill chime in...

I had an Anakin ad still have a maul from singapore. Not bad for a few times a year Halloween type costume. Maul is not accurate, fabrics are wrong, but the patterns are ok. I wouldnt go as far as say good, just ok. The Anakin I sold had way mor things wrong than I wanted to fix, so starting over was a better option. I did get good service from him, and he even replaced som items missed in shipping.
 
I bought some stuff from him too. His Indy MKVII bag is not accurate and smaller than the real deal. His Indy fedora is seriously pathetic... its a hard wool felt hat (I bought it before I knew better about Indy Fedoras; now I have an Akubra and an Adventurebilt!). I recently bought BSG rank pins from him and thank God they're good lookin'.

I bought the Indy bag as well, It looks better on eBay.
It's way too long in comparison to the width of the bag and it has lining that shouldn't be there.
And dont even get me started on the plastic?? strap when I got the bag the entire strap was sticking together.
 
From what I see the tabbards for the Jedi tunic. It is horrible. I dunno if Simon Poon, the owner is willing to study the costumes before he actually attempts it. He's now modivated to make screen accurate. I've purchase his Anakin costume last October, and planned to dress out to CIV. So I ran into TFN that the costumes are far from inaccuracies. So I quickly upgraded as I can and try to locate the vendors who can make me the parts. So I was close to missing the costumes before CIV, but finished right before CIV happened. Whooo. That was quite a sweat and distress.

As my friend said that people buys his costumes literally just because it was labeled and descripted as the costumes and hundreds of dollars. So I might of convinced us to buying his costumes. Though, his materials he used aren't great and inconvenient to use.

I still happened to have his Anakin costume I've bought last year and haven't gotten rid of it. But the Han Solo outfit I've heard wasn't that bad. Well the boots for Anakin could work alright, by changing the spats basically. Plus three heel ridges on the back.

His costumes are perfect for the cosplaying or role playing, but definately won't get you into 501st Legion, if you dress as Anakin wearing Singapore costumes. Well, I've gotta study his Imperial Cap, to see whether is right on earth. Hehe.
 
Back
Top