Am I REALLY the only one disappointed with TFA?

That, and subsequent scenes featuring the Falcon (crashing through trees, skipping off of snow-covered ground like a rock across the surface of a pond), bothered me.
The deflector shields should be activated protecting the Falcon against direct impact... but, no, I didn't notice any shield shimmer either on Jakku or on the Starkiller base planet.
 
The deflector shields should be activated protecting the Falcon against direct impact... but, no, I didn't notice any shield shimmer either on Jakku or on the Starkiller base planet.
Has their ever been a shimmer? during shootouts it just looked like laser explosions
 
When do you ever see deflector shields shimmer in Star Wars?,....apart from in TPM (Gungang elephant things)

You see laser blasts hitting hulls and dispersing,...thats it,....no shimmering,...thats Star Trek

J
 
I think the only time there's been a shimmer is when Anakin's fighter starts back up in the control ship in TPM. Gungans and droidekas excepted, I've always liked the subtle way SW shields have always been handled. All but invisible.
 
The first thing Fin gets/reminds Rey to do once flying the Falcon was to get the shields up,....the Falcon couldn't fly in atmosphere at speed without shields as the friction would rip the dish & greeblies off,......so when Han ripped through the trees & skidded on the snow the Falcon was well wrapped up & protected,.....well ...to a limit......the lower turret & underside were not damaged at all

J
 
Good for you! I hope you continue to enjoy and wish I could share that with you!.....
No, I was only funning with the name [emoji6] believe me, I am the last person to have a go at someone on grammar. I have a hard enough time on a regular keyboard. Get me on a phone or tablet and its a wonder i can type my nmae. [emoji106]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The deflector shields should be activated protecting the Falcon against direct impact... but, no, I didn't notice any shield shimmer either on Jakku or on the Starkiller base planet.
The first thing Fin gets/reminds Rey to do once flying the Falcon was to get the shields up,....the Falcon couldn't fly in atmosphere at speed without shields as the friction would rip the dish & greeblies off,......so when Han ripped through the trees & skidded on the snow the Falcon was well wrapped up & protected,.....well ...to a limit......the lower turret & underside were not damaged at all

J
See? Phony baloney technology explains everything. I might as well have been watching Star Trek: The Next Generation. :lol
 
Video game physics, perhaps by design to overlap with game products.

I dated a gal who was a nurse. Every time we watched ER, she would roll her eyes and proclaim what the correct procedure would be. Pilots do the same when we see CGI/film aerodynamics that look off.

Ill go watch it again during a matinee to pick up on all the things that I missed. I did catch the Training Remote on the falcon though.
 
Lol, I worked on that show for 8 seasons - I can't even tell you about the endless CRATES of mail we'd get about what we we're doing wrong...

Boy do I get it Willie, 99% of the watchers will never know the mistakes. I used to just nudge her and tell her to pipe down. I also have to tell myself its a space ship and doesnt fly like a real plane haha.
 
Almost all SW ships just have engines that point backwards and that's it. No control surfaces for in the air, no reaction control system for in space.
The Y-Wing did have little fins in the very back of the nacelles, the snowspeeders did have some speed brakes that seemed to help turn them.
Other than that, no hint of how they could do anything but obey Newton's third law. But that is a sin of many many Sci Fi vehicles.
Hell at least Star Trek added a RCS system to the Enterprise for the movies.
SW gets a pass mostly, it's not hard Sci Fi, it's another animal. Magical force field technology help steer, act as heat shield and mimic atmospheric flight in space because... well because. But the MF taking ground strikes and no damage is sort of pushing it.
 
Last edited:
Another desert planet orphan that has information about a Death Star super weapon inside a droid that the bad guys desperately want!!??

Thomas

*puts on nerd glasses and adds stereotypical rhaspy prepubecent nerd voice*

Uh actually, if you go back and watch the movie again, you will notice that the "information about the Death Star super weapon", is actually a map to Luke Skywalker. If your gonna be a nerd, at least get the facts straight.
 
I dated a gal who was a nurse. Every time we watched ER, she would roll her eyes and proclaim what the correct procedure would be...
I have a good friend who is a former firefighter/paramedic/EMT, and he would groan audibly every time he saw a truly botched medical procedure in a television show or movie, then proceed to explain every little thing they did wrong. I finally had to stop watching stuff with him. :lol
 
Regarding ships with "just" rear engines. When in doubt, the answer is repulsor lifts. The sonic screwdriver of Star Wars locomotion.
 
Back
Top