Yeah mine sounds like it's ripping when I take it off too. Guess it's just because of how tight it is. Overall I am pretty happy, but as AJ said, a lot of them are off-center. I ordered 3 sizes in case one didn't fit then I could go up or down, but 2 of them were pretty off-center. Luckily the one that fit is the one that's centered, but if it shrinks in the wash, I'm screwed. I also think the art is kind of squished. But the shirt itself is pretty nice despite the ripping sound. It's warm and soft for what it is.
Has anybody washed theirs yet? I am wondering how it will hold up as far as shrinkage since they're already so small.