Batman black eye make up

There is probably already a thread on this but...

Re: black eye make up especially for Batman

So far I have only used Ben Nye make up and Maybelline eyeliner and black eye shadow. I was fairly happy with it as long as I take a little time with it. I saw someone post at the Brotherhood of the Bat forum stating they use black liquid latex. I had forgotten that I had some so I tried it out and I think I like it! I will still have to use eye liner on my lash line/tear duct and rather than powdering with regular make up setting powder I used black eye shadow to coat the latex to keep it from sticking to itself on my eye lids. The whole thing did clean off a lot easier than the black grease make up. I think I will used the latex from now on.

So, what do you other Batmen (Batmans?) use to blacken your eyes?

I know folks use eye black, the same product football players use.

Eye Black always seems to run if it's hot. Going to a Con in a rubber mask definitely makes for a sweaty mess. I use Maybeline EyeStudio Lasting Drama Gel Liner. It doesn't run!

First time I cosplayed Nightwing I used my girlfriend's eye shadow and eye liner. It looked pretty great, held up in the heat. But when it came to taking it off. It just wasn't happening.

I use L'oreal Blackest Black Gel Eyeliner http://www.ulta.com/infallible-gel-lacquer-liner-24-hour?productId=xlsImpprod4480165.

It will not run and you better have good makeup remover wipes to get it off after otherwise you're gonna look like you went to a MCR concert for a couple days after.

These ones worked great for removing for me: https://pics.drugstore.com/prodimg/79133/450.jpg